The state’s two largest utility companies have been pleading poverty so consistently, it’s almost as if their repeated pleading of it will make it in fact true.
In fact, much of the media’s coverage of the California energy “crisis” seems to accept as fact the notion that PG&E Corp. and Southern California Edison are in financial straits mainly as a result of having their hands tied on rate increases and having to pay escalating costs for power in the state’s failed experiment with deregulation.
Those factors, of course, have played some role in the “crisis.” But while the power companies come calling for a $12 billion bailout, taxpayers and legislators alike should not lose sight of the following:
Even as their financial troubles mounted and wholesale electricity rates jumped, Edison and PG&E gave top executives hefty raises and transferred billions of dollars to their parent companies in the past three years.
Specifically, from 1996 through late-2000 , PG&E— which serves central and northern California— passed along $4.7 billion to its parent company, which in turn spent $1.9 billion paying dividends to stockholders and $2.7 billion buying back stock.
Southern California Edison, which serves most of Southern California including the Santa Clarita Valley, essentially did the same: While supposedly racking up the debt that it now wants taxpayers to shoulder, Edison transferred $4.8 billion to its parent company, Edison International. The parent, in turn, paid $1.6 billion in dividends and bought back $2.7 billion in stock.
In other words, some people were making a lot of money from California’s electricity market, and now the utilities are pleading poverty and threatening bankruptcy.
Less important— but just as galling to ratepayers who don’t know how they’ll afford triple-digit electrical bills— is the fact that the top executives of PG&E and Southern California Edison have each had their cash compensation increase by about $1 million in the past several years. If you include bonuses tied to stock performance and dividends, each of the company’s chief executives is hauling in more than $2 million per year.
Poverty indeed.
The more salient point, though, is the fact that both companies siphoned billions in cash away to be funneled to executives and their parent companies’ stockholders, all the while Rome was burning: Billions in uncollected customer payments were piling up, wholesale rates were increasing and other debts were amassing.
The party, obviously, is over— both PG&E and Edison announced they would not pay dividends last month.
And while they ask us to bail them out, everyone would be well-advised to remember that, as they cast blame toward Gov. Gray Davis, among others, for the so-called crisis, California’s utility giants should also point a finger straight at the nearest mirror.
