Suffering from the consequences of a bond measure that failed by 11 votes and witnessing the recent public spectacle of a flawed presidential election, William S. Hart Union High School District Superintendent Robert Lee sent a letter to the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors asking for election procedure reforms Tuesday.
The supervisors are examining a proposal to spend $100 million to replace the old punch card machines with new touch screen voting technology.
In the eight page letter, Lee chronicled the Hart district chain of election events including two failed bond measures and a hand recount of ballots cast in the second which revealed a host of inconsistencies.
“Local control by popular vote— be it simple majority or supermajority— the election process must ensure that every vote cast is a vote that is counted,” Lee included in the letter.
Lee said the Hart district concern regarding the election process began during the first election conducted on Nov. 2, 1999. The measure failed by a margin of 1.47 percent. The Hart district board of trustees addressed concerns, which were resolved by the following election— Measure S.
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder reported defeat of the measure by one-tenth of one percent, which prompted a recount.
Lee pointed out that even though Measure S was a single issue item on the ballot, the recount indicated 196 voters went to the trouble to travel to the polls but did not vote for or against. An additional 40 voters cast no vote on their absentee ballots, but paid for postage anyway. Another 131 votes were recovered in the hand count, which for some reason had never been tallied in the machine count.
Seven voters received ballots for the Claremont School District and 14 received ballots for the Wiseburn School District. These ballots were then remade by election officials and counted.
At local polling places, the flat-ended round dowels used for the punch cards were sometimes missing, resulting in partially detached and hanging chads that left questions regarding the intent of the voter.
Lee also made a plea for the Office of the Registrar-Recorder to create some long term public good by contacting voters when they have cast a vote in error and the proper procedure for the future.
