This cannot be taken lightly.
‘On the whole the lawsuit and its allegations combine to paint a picture of a city management that was less concerned with the public good than it was with covering its own posterior and keeping an objecting employee from squawking.’
The more answers we learn about the city’s handling of its trash franchises, the more disturbing the information. Now, even as we were expressing serious reservations about the question of whether the city was honoring its fiduciary duty to taxpayers when it failed to responsibly negotiate reductions in local trash hauling rates, we find out that the problem may go much deeper than simple mismanagement.
It may be criminal.
Court records show that the city of Santa Clarita in 1999 paid a hefty settlement— approximately $325,000— to Hazel Joanes, the city’s former solid waste coordinator who alleged she was harassed and fired after she made too much noise at City Hall about enormous profits being derived by trash haulers at the expense of taxpayers’ best interests.
The judge in the case found some merit in Joanes’ lawsuit, and before it could go to trial, the city settled it.
Joanes’ testimony in the wrongful termination lawsuit, if even only partially accurate, is damning and should result in an official criminal investigation to determine whether any crimes occurred and who committed them.
In her lawsuit, Joanes said she discovered in 1996 that the three city-franchised trash haulers— Atlas, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal— were to receive a more than 25-percent cut in the fees they paid to dump trash at area landfills. While city officials say the costs of the addition of the green waste recycling program offset those tipping fee decreases, the tipping fees have dropped even more since then— substantially— yet trash rates remained constant. Clearly, the city and the haulers have never bothered to pass any cost savings on to the taxpayers.
Joanes says she was shut down, and when she disputed the matter, she was eventually harassed and fired by City Manager George Caravalho and then-Deputy City Manager Lynn Harris, who, according to court records, reportedly told Joanes to “consider reformulating her views (about trash rates) or possibly ‘end up like Jimmy Hoffa.’”
There are many sordid details, some still unproven, that emerge as one peruses the thousands of pages of records that chronicle the years-long court battle over Joanes’ termination— ranging from a romantic relationship between two top city staffers to an allegation that the waste haulers had leverage over Caravalho in the form of a videotape of him leaving a motel room with someone other than his wife.
Additionally, several city sources have told The Signal of political threats issued by haulers during the recent debates over the exclusive city trash hauling contracts.
On the whole the lawsuit and its allegations combine to paint a picture of a city management that was less concerned with the public good than it was with covering its own posterior and keeping an objecting employee from squawking. Perhaps what’s even more disconcerting is the fact that the City Council at the time of the settlement apparently was not given accurate or complete information about the nature or content of the lawsuit and settlement.
Even if this picture is only partially accurate, the City Council will have no choice but to make some major changes at City Hall.
The next obvious step is to bring about an official government inquiry— from an agency other than the city— into the conduct of all of those involved in the Joanes case and anyone who may have been involved in either a violation of the public’s trust or the blackmail of a government official.
It is not a matter to be disregarded, and given the new information the City Council members have, we expect our elected officials will do the right thing.
