ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Lawsuit Trashes City Hall

City paid $325,000 in 1999 to ex-staffer who alleges superiors told her to keep quiet about trash rates.

The city of Santa Clarita paid $325,000 to settle a lawsuit in which its former solid waste coordinator accused the city manager and his deputy of gouging the public through trash rates.

Hazel Joanes, the city’s staff member in charge of trash from 1991 to 1996, filed a wrongful termination lawsuit against the city and, personally, City Manager George Caravalho and former Deputy City Manager Lynn Harris, accusing them of threatening, harassing and firing her because she disagreed with a trash rate hike and wouldn’t keep quiet.

Thousands of pages of court documents spanning nearly three years fill two large file boxes at the county courthouse in downtown Los Angeles.

The case centered on Joanes’ claim that she was fired for attempting to prevent the city from making “a gift of public funds to the haulers” by hiking trash rates beyond the actual cost of service and a reasonable profit margin.

In 1996, under the city’s exclusive contracts with its three waste haulers— Blue Barrel, Santa Clarita Disposal Co. and Atlas Transport— customers’ trash rates were supposed to go up or down if the haulers’ costs went up or down.

In her lawsuit, Joanes said she discovered the haulers would be receiving a $10 cut in tipping fees (the amount they pay to dump trash at the landfill). Joanes said she tried to convince her superiors that residential and commercial trash rates should be correspondingly lowered. Instead, customer rates were raised by $1.50 when Harris renegotiated the contracts.

Joanes said Harris told her to “get on board” with the trash rate hike, and Caravalho accused her of being “insubordinate” when she balked at Harris’ insistence on raising trash rates.

Joanes took a leave of absence, filed a workers compensation claim for stress and submitted to a psychiatric evaluation. The psychiatrist reported that Joanes was told by Harris to “consider reformulating her views (about trash rates) or possibly ‘end up like Jimmy Hoffa.’”

Joanes was fired and filed a Superior Court lawsuit July 8, 1997.

In testimony under oath, Joanes told the court she had been informed that “the haulers have something on George (Caravalho), and that is with regard to a videotape that the haulers have of George coming out of a motel room with a female that wasn’t his wife... and that is why... nothing has been done about the rates.”

Joanes identified the woman, a former city staff member, by name.

The city’s attorney said the evidence— also relayed to the City Council in what the attorneys called an “anonymous letter” — was speculative and irrelevant, but that if Caravalho was being blackmailed by a hauler it would have given him cause to ignore Joanes’ recommendation to cut trash rates.

“(If) such a videotape existed, was in the possession of a trash hauler and was used by a trash hauler to blackmail the city manager, such evidence may be relevant to show that (the) city manager had a motive to ignore (Joanes’) view on the rates for trash hauling services and to silence her as (she) alleges,” the city’s attorney in the case, Timothy L. Davis, told the court. “However, there is no evidence that the tape exists.”

On Wednesday, Caravalho said he never heard of such a videotape until asked about it Wednesday by a reporter, and that the city attorney never told him it was an allegation in Joanes’ lawsuit.

“It’s news to me,” Caravalho said. “I have never heard of a tape. I didn’t know anything about that.”

City Attorney Carl Newton said Wednesday that Caravalho knew about the tape in the context of the lawsuit.

“He knew of a claim of the existence of the tape,” Newton said.

In reference to the “anonymous letter” that purportedly made similar references to a videotape, Caravalho said, “As I remember, there were a lot of allegations put out in a flier that was circulated at City Hall. Somebody showed it to me. It contained a lot of innuendo and distortions of the fact. I threw it in the trash can.”

He said he did not remember specific allegations.

Steve Arklin, who founded Santa Clarita Disposal with his brothers in 1970 and sold the company in 1999 to Waste Management Inc., said he knew nothing of the alleged videotape— and doesn’t believe the allegation is fair to Caravalho.

“That’s a pretty sad thing to say about a family man and a respected man in our community,” he said. “That’s an interesting story to come up with, but it’s certainly one that I never heard around the trash haulers.”

Nazareth Chobanian, one-time president of Blue Barrel, said he knew nothing of a videotape.

Caravalho said in court papers that he denied all of Joanes’ allegations and she was fired “for refusing to return to work after an eight-month absence from the city.”

Joanes said she didn’t return from her approved leave because she was still under a doctor’s care for job-related stress, and for fear of reprisal.

The city challenged Joanes’ first seven-count lawsuit and a judge ruled it void on March 1, 1999. Joanes refiled a two-count lawsuit a month later and the judge upheld her claim that the city violated her right to free speech.

Caravalho said Wednesday, “I wanted to go to trial because I felt that the charges and allegations were totally unfounded and I wanted an impartial jury to review that.”

Instead, the city decided to pay her in November 1999, two months before trial was to begin.

* * *

While Joanes was still on leave she filed a grievance with the city alleging she was mistreated. Caravalho put Assistant City Manager Ken Pulskamp in charge of an internal city investigation that relied on information from Harris.

“I was requested by the city manager to investigate (Joanes’) allegations dealing with public policy,” Pulskamp said in a confidential memo to the city attorney.

Joanes’ attorney, Samuel Wells, questioned the credibility of Pulskamp’s investigation because Pulskamp and the accused— Harris— had been involved romantically.

“Both defendant Lynn Harris and Kenneth Pulskamp... admitted at deposition that they were involved in a non-working relationship in 1995,” Wells told the court. “Given the fact that Mr. Pulskamp was charged with investigating allegations of misconduct against his former paramour, the existence of that prior relationship is relevant to the jury’s assessment of whether or not Mr. Pulskamp conducted an unbiased investigation.”

He continued, “The fact that defendant Caravalho assigned Mr. Pulskamp to investigate the alleged wrongdoing of his former paramour is relevant to assess whether defendant Caravalho actually intended to conduct a fair, unbiased investigation.”

Caravalho said Wednesday that when he put Pulskamp in charge of the investigation of Joanes’ public-policy complaints, “There wasn’t anything to substantiate that at the time (the relationship between Pulskamp and Harris). I didn’t know that.”

He said personnel director Jenny Roney investigated other aspects of Joanes’ complaint and Roney and Pulskamp “were the best people. I thought they did an excellent job” and handled the matter professionally.

Pulskamp said Wednesday he felt his study was unbiased.

“When I got into the study, I didn’t know much about it,” he said.

* * *

Mayor Laurene Weste, who joined the City Council 19 months before the settlement was reached, said staff members never told the council about the specific allegations in the lawsuit— only that Caravalho, Pulskamp and a city attorney said Joanes was a problem employee and it would be “too hard on staff” if the case went to trial.

“I knew about the settlement,” Weste said. “We did not know what was in the case except that she was an insubordinate employee.”

There was no mention from staff of a videotape or anonymous letter, Weste said.

Caravalho said Wednesday the city attorney would have been the one to inform the council of the court proceedings, and while Caravalho “would have been present” at the closed-door meetings, he did not know what the council was told.

“You should ask the city attorney,” he said.

City Attorney Newton said the council received a full report on the settlement. No council members were given any documents related to the lawsuit, nor did any of them request them, he said.

Councilwoman Jo Anne Darcy said she did not recall hearing about the trash aspect of the Joanes lawsuit and did not know it focused on allegations that Joanes was ordered to keep mum about the rates.

“I didn’t think her leaving was because of that,” Darcy said. “She did not get along with (Harris). She criticized her greatly.... There may have been a grudge between her and Lynn. They did not get along, we knew that.”

Darcy said she remembered being updated on the progress of the lawsuit but was not given many details. “I know it was going on a long time and they wished to get it settled.”

Former Councilwoman Jill Klajic said she received “massive” information about the lawsuit in closed session.

“We were given tons of information,” she said. Klajic, who has served two separate four-year terms, was on the council when the trash franchises were negotiated and when the lawsuit was in court.

Klajic said she felt uncomfortable discussing other matters related to the case because they were confidential.

Jan Heidt, a member of the City Council when the lawsuit was settled, said she does not place much credence in Joanes’ allegations.

“The problem with Hazel was that she kept insisting that the greenwaste program could be done for nothing by the haulers, but she never presented any data to support that claim,” Heidt said.

Asked about the videotape allegation, Heidt was incredulous. “That sounds a little farfetched.”

* * *

Superior Court Judge Ralph W. Dau paraphrased Joanes’ testimony during proceedings: “She was pointing out to the city that the information they were putting out to the public as the reasons for their actions (raising trash rates) were incorrect, and that for her persistence in saying those things, she was harassed and made ill and unable to work.”

Joanes said she recommended in 1995 that the city audit the haulers’ books. Otherwise the City Council “could not properly determine whether the rates being charged to the citizens... were reasonably based upon the cost of providing such service.” She also asserted that the city was not getting all of the revenue to which it was entitled. City staff recommended an audit, Joanes said, but the council “refused to authorize any such audit.”

Harris said in deposition that she received a call from Darcy, then mayor, telling her the haulers should not be audited because they are private companies and should be left alone. Harris said she shared the call with Caravalho and Pulskamp.

Darcy said Wednesday she does not remember telling Harris the haulers should not be audited, but did recall a conversation in which, based on Harris’ statements, she conceded it was not the right time to do an audit.

“(Harris) said, ‘We probably don’t need an audit,’” Darcy said. “It was not stressed that we have to do an audit, and I said, ‘Well, if you feel that way, I guess we don’t.’”

Interviewed last week, the 1996 council members said they did not remember the staff asking for permission to audit the haulers. Darcy said Caravalho told her the haulers didn’t want an audit and that Karl McCarthy, general manager of Blue Barrel-Santa Clarita Disposal, lobbied against an audit. McCarthy denied the allegation.

Joanes said in court documents, “Harris told me that since the City Council had elected not to audit the haulers, the actual receipts of the haulers were not proper concern of the city staff, and that I should not concern myself with this issue.... Nevertheless, because I believed the matter to be one of public concern... I continued to bring the matter to the attention of defendant Harris and to suggest that without having information about the haulers’ revenues, the rates being set... by the City Council could not be set at cost plus a reasonable profit.”

Joanes told the court that the city repeatedly told citizens “that the rates which they were being charged were based upon the cost of providing the hauling service, including a reasonable profit for the haulers.”

But “Harris advised me that she did not care about the profit margins to be earned by the haulers, and that they could make a 200 percent profit and it would be none of (her) concern,” Joanes said.

Pulskamp, in his memo to the city attorney, said Harris “did feel that the haulers were an extension of staff” because they perform a function, namely trash service, on behalf of the city.

Nonetheless, Caravalho noted Wednesday that he asked the council to put the trash franchises to bid when they came up for renewal in 2000. The council voted instead for a one-year extension of the agreements with the haulers and gave instruction to staff to negotiate lower trash rates within six months.

Caravalho said the council then removed the six-month stipulation and directed the staff to renegotiate the contracts with the haulers. The council approved new franchise agreements with the existing haulers March 13, although they have not yet been signed.

* * *

Court papers show that when Joanes learned in 1996 that landfill rates were to be lowered and the haulers were also to receive a tax rebate, she told her superiors the savings should be passed on to the customers. She alleged the rates were already too high when Harris hiked them by another $1.50 when the greenwaste recycling program was launched.

“The haulers were being allowed to charge the citizens for pass-through costs which had not actually been incurred by the haulers,” Joanes’ attorney argued.

Joanes “then told the defendant that the cost figures used for the yard trimmings (greenwaste) portion of the rate were too high, that the residential rates already being charged included erroneous and possibly illegal charges, that the overall cost to the haulers of waste hauling was about to substantially decrease— which would lower, not increase or freeze, the current residential rates— and that the commercial rates which Ms. Harris also was recommending were probably producing excessive profits to the haulers.”

Joanes’ attorney said that in response to her concerns “the city, through Ms. Harris and George Caravalho, the city manager, harassed and berated her.”

Joanes said Harris had her participate in a “mock” City Council session prior to the real one, to go over potential questions from the council about the trash rate hike. Joanes said she was ordered to discourage the public from showing up and testifying at the real council meeting.

Pulskamp said in his memo to the city attorney that he was informed the haulers were making a profit of 7.5 percent but that Joanes believed with the rate and tax cuts the haulers’ profit margin would increase to 20 percent to 30 percent. Pulskamp said Joanes reported that the haulers’ tipping fees would be cut from $34.88 per ton of trash to $25.59, starting Oct. 1, 1996.

Pulskamp said in the memo that Joanes and other solid waste staff members were told to substantiate their calculations “to see if the $1.50 per month (for greenwaste recycling) could be reduced. When their work was completed, Dennis Luppens, a solid waste management analyst... told the city manager that the numbers were ‘smoke and mirrors’ and that $1.50 was a better rate than any calculations could justify. With that, the program was implemented.”

On Wednesday, Arklin acknowledged that the tipping fees dropped but said the addition of new programs like greenwaste recycling amounted to new, added costs for trucks and drivers.

“At the same time we were implementing programs that were actually more than the drop of the tipping fee,” he said.

The trash rates were designed to be fair, he said, and the discussion ended up being “where I wanted it to be more and (the city) wanted it to be less. That’s probably a good place to stop.”

Two years ago the haulers’ landfill tipping fees were reportedly cut again when the local Chiquita Canyon Landfill operations changed hands. Again there was no corresponding cut in residential or commercial trash rates. Last week McCarthy of Blue Barrel confirmed that his tipping fees prior to a new contract in February 1999 were “a helluva lot more than they are now.”

In May 1999, three months after the second cut in tipping fees and during the time the city was trying to convince the court it hadn’t set trash rates arbitrarily, the city altered the trash contracts to eliminate the link between tipping fees and trash rates.

Although the affected city staff members knew the tipping fee amounts in 1996, city spokeswoman Gail Ortiz said last week that the city does not know how much the tipping fees are now or were before 1999. The haulers refuse to disclose the amounts.

Signal Managing Editor Tim Whyte contributed to this story.

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/main/0501/051701a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,827 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:v2_datefile_main
  • byline:staff_marker [Managing Editor; Signal Managing Editor]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/12 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council, Chiquita Canyon]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 8, national 0