Make no mistake: Nothing is settled when it comes to Santa Clarita’s trash situation, and the details of what exactly has gone wrong are only starting to emerge.
But if the picture we’re seeing is an accurate one, it means millions of dollars in excess profits derived by the three local franchised trash haulers in the past half-dozen years.
‘Those errant numbers remain in effect today, and if the city signs its new 10-year deal with the haulers, the error will be perpetuated for the next decade.’
At best, it’s an example of frightening municipal negligence.
The Signal has learned that, when the city raised local trash rates in 1996, the increase was not only based on the added cost of adding greenwaste recycling, but also on inaccurate tipping fee information.
A tipping fee is the amount a hauler pays to dump trash at a landfill, and it is just one of the costs plugged into a formula that was used to determine what should have been an appropriate residential trash rate.
The fee used in the formula in 1996 was $34.33— which was actually approximately $ 8-plus per ton more than the haulers were actually paying. Rather, the $34.33 fee was the so-called “gate rate” at the local landfill, the amount an independent hauler might pay at the landfill gate without having benefit of a contract calling for a lower fee.
In reality, the local haulers pay much less than the gate rate because they have long-term contracts with the dumps, guaranteeing them a lower rate. There’s nothing wrong with that, so long as the lower fees are not used to skim extra profits from public franchises. It’s not like these are companies operating in an open marketplace.
In 1996, the haulers’ actual tipping fees were believed to be between $25 and $26 per ton, but the city calculated your trash bill based on a fee roughly equal to the gate rate.
Those errant numbers remain in effect today, and if the city signs its new 10-year deal with the haulers, the error will be perpetuated for the next decade.
That’s a lot of extra taxpayer cash going straight to the out-of-town corporate parents of the local trash haulers. It’s difficult to put your finger on just how much, because the city has to date demanded so little information from the haulers.
Oddly, the city is short on documentation of just how the $34.33 figure came into play. City officials say some records appear to be missing, so piecing together the history of the artificially inflated fees is apparently difficult.
It’s just the latest in oddities about the city trash franchises.
The City Council has finally indicated its intent to order an audit of the haulers’ records dating back to 1991, and it seems like every additional piece of information that surfaces reinforces the notion that the council’s decision will be better late than never.
