ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Black ’n Whyte

Vigilance, consequences, hope for healing

Did you tell the truth?

Did you do what you thought was right at the time?

Those questions were posed by a lady I know in the aftermath of our stories last week regarding the lawsuit and settlement between the city of Santa Clarita and former city employee Hazel Joanes.

The answers were, “yes,” even though that may be difficult to believe for a lot of people who have turned to blaming this newspaper for the very real problems that exist at City Hall.

The words “Vigilance Forever” appear on the nameplate of The Signal, right up at the top of the front page of every edition. We take those two words seriously. That doesn’t mean we’re perfect— we’re not— but it is a philosophy we attempt to uphold.

It is the philosophy we have been exercising on the matters of the city trash franchises, including our story about the Joanes wrongful termination lawsuit, in which she claimed city management told her to keep quiet about her claims that residents were paying inflated trash rates.

The day after our story on the lawsuit, in which Joanes received a $325,000 settlement rather than go to trial, the City Council held a special meeting to decide whether to fire City Manager George Caravalho.

They didn’t. And, because the council chose to have that meeting the day after our story on the Joanes lawsuit appeared, many people assumed the story was THE reason— the only reason— that the meeting occurred.

That’s not true. The story may have affected the timing, but that meeting was coming. Truth be told, just about anyone who closely follows local politics knew Caravalho was already in hot water with more than one City Council member, perhaps even a majority. Several council members— not just Mayor Laurene Weste, who is taking a lot of heat for her outspoken approach— felt as if Caravalho does not always faithfully follow the council’s direction.

But when the council members emerged from closed session May 18, they came out, at least publicly, unified behind Caravalho, and all five, even Weste, chastised the local newspaper for its story the previous day.

Knowing what I know about how several council members felt prior to the publication of that story, and how easily they seem to have been swayed, I have only this to say to them:

So much for having the courage of your convictions.

The one up side of the council’s meeting was that the council members finally seemed to come around to the notion that they need to order an audit of the three franchised trash haulers before signing new contracts. If the taxpayer shakedown is as bad as it seems, now is the time to adjust the situation.

Our stories on the Joanes lawsuit were designed to accurately reflect the public record on an issue that has assumed great local political importance: The question of whether, through mismanagement or something worse, the city’s leaders, both elected and appointed, have protected the interests of the three local franchised trash haulers rather than the taxpayers.

Yes, there was one factual error that we know of in two days of reporting: One of our writers characterized the judge’s ruling incorrectly, and we published a front-page correction the very next day. Further, there were a couple of sins of omission, which we were more than glad to clarify, on the front page, when they were called to our attention. It’s no excuse, but when you review thousands of pages of records, that can happen.

Other than that, the stories were accurate. That doesn’t mean everything everyone said in the stories was true; it means we accurately told the public what the public record contained about the Joanes lawsuit.

It means we were accurate when we said Joanes claimed to have knowledge of a videotape that was being used by the haulers to persuade Caravalho to act in their best interests, rather than the taxpayers’ best interests. And we were accurate when we reported that city attorneys had pointed out there was no physical evidence to prove that the videotape actually exists.

That’s all part of the public record, and you can go to the county courthouse and read it for yourself. We didn’t make it up. One of our jobs is to tell you what the public record says, and sometimes the public record contains testimony that is conflicting or incorrect. I’m reminded of the instance a few years ago in which a local football star was accused of rape. He was later cleared— but we accurately reported the public record of the story, starting with the allegations and proceeding all the way to the resolution of the case.

Do I believe the Caravalho videotape exists? I have my doubts.

But I think Joanes was right about a lot of more important things. I believe she was right about the massive rip-off , intentional or otherwise, that was perpetrated upon local taxpayers by the city’s mishandling of the trash contracts. If you do the math, even conservatively, the figure is in the millions over the past half-dozen years, and during that time no one at City Hall bothered to order an audit of the haulers until concepts like “sex,” “extortion,” “favors” and “blackmail” started to make their way into the discourse.

We now know that, when the city set new trash rates in 1996, supposedly based on the haulers’ costs, it used a “tipping fee” — the amount haulers pay at the local dump— that was actually far greater than what the haulers paid at the time, and their fees have dropped since then, not risen.

It’s not chump change. It appears to be much more significant than a typical taxpayer realizing they pay a couple of dollars too much on their monthly bill. Even if your monthly bill has been just $1.67 too high for the past six years, that’s more than $3.6 million— just from single-family residential fees—Êfleeing the local economy via excess profit for the haulers, beyond the 7.5 percent originally included in the contracts.

I’m betting it’s worse, but hopefully the long-sought audit of the haulers will finally shed some light on the situation. Perhaps we’ve been all wrong about it, and the audit will tell. If that proves to be the case, and the audit appears reliable, then at least we’ll know, for a change. Until May 18, the official city policy was to keep its head buried as deeply into the beach as possible. One can’t help wondering why.

Unfortunately, many of these valid questions have been overlooked in the past week because everyone has been so busy trying to kill the messenger over the question of whether our stories should have included the allegation by Joanes regarding “the tape.”

If I had it all to do over again, yes, maybe I’d do some things differently. Maybe I wouldn’t. In the newspaper business, you often make your tough decisions on deadline— leaving plenty of opportunity for Monday morning quarterbacking. In this instance, I regret that the real focus of the story— legitimate questions about trash rates and the apparent loss of millions of dollars of taxpayers’ money— became overshadowed by the debate over “the tape.”

In all, it has been a regrettable situation, and it is a situation that, despite the relative pause in the action, is far from resolved. I hope, though, that the council’s decision to order an audit will constitute the beginning of a healing process. The process itself may yet prove painful, but it’s what we need.

As I turn these things over in my head, and think of the things I could have done differently or better, I also remember the words of that lady I know, and the exchange she had with a colleague of mine:

“Did you tell the truth?”

“Yes.”

“Did you do what you thought was right at the time?”

“Yes.”

“Well, isn’t that the definition of Vigilance Forever?”

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.

Image not recoveredmugwhyte.jpg

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/0501/052701b.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,335 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/3 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 8, national 0