A little perspective is needed in the greater Southern California community college sports world.
If, indeed, the allegations of “illegal recruiting” against College of the Canyons football coaches prove to be true, here’s what the actual offense amounts to: Cougar coaches wore clothing with COC logos to two regional high school all-star games, and talked to a pair of players at one of the games.
Stop the presses.
Yes, rules are rules. And if the California Commission of Athletics Constitution says coaches can’t “mingle” with players outside their college’s recruiting area, and if that constitution further says coaches can’t wear school apparel on scouting trips outside their recruiting area, then the coaches should abide by those rules.
But these allegations remind us of the fact that some rules are just patently stupid.
The allegations go something like this: Two members of the COC coaching staff were reportedly seen by two members of the Antelope Valley College coaching staff talking to a pair of Antelope Valley high school players after the High Desert Coaches Association High School All-Star Game on June 12. The Antelope Valley coaches contend the Cougar coaches were wearing school logo apparel.
It’s not like they were caught offering the players cash, cars and prostitutes.
But Antelope Valley College apparently intends to file a formal complaint about the alleged recruiting rules violation, unlike Glendale College, which has also accused COC of a similar violation: Glendale’s coach alleges he saw a pair of COC staffers wearing school logo jackets and golf shirts in the stands at the Valley High School All-Star Game at Cal State Northridge on June 5.
Glendale officials, however, have said they don’t plan to take formal action, opting instead to handle their gripe with a phone call to COC Athletic Director Len Mohney and a letter to COC Superintendent-President Dianne Van Hook.
That really should be all that’s necessary: Rules are rules, and if wearing school logo apparel outside your recruiting area is against the rules, the COC coaches should be admonished not to do so again. Doing things like filing formal complaints just ups the ante over what was, apparently, a minor violation.
All of this fallout over the wearing of sporty Cougar apparel has served as a reminder of just how absurd some rules can be.
For example, COC coaches are denied the ability to “recruit” in the Antelope Valley, which on the surface seems fair enough because there is a community college in the Antelope Valley. But all recruiting areas aren’t created equal, and one can’t help but wonder how much of an advantage it must be to have a recruiting area the size of the Antelope Valley versus a recruiting area the size of the Santa Clarita Valley. And don’t forget that, for most of the past 20 years, Antelope Valley College has had the entire north Los Angeles County area to itself, and may now be hypersensitive to a new competitor with the reinstatement last year of football at COC after an 18-year absence.
Even more ridiculous is the ban on apparel outside one’s recruiting area. Does anyone really think harm is caused when a community college coach, while scouting a high school all-star game, wears a windbreaker or a polo shirt with a team logo on it?
Of course not. Most college coaches will privately acknowledge that such rules are just plain silly.
That they are. Obviously, everyone should do their best to comply— including the coaches at COC— but the California community college athletic establishment ought to take a serious look at its rules, and devise some changes that make the rules more fair, equitable and sensible.
It’s fine to ban cash, cars and prostitutes from the recruiting process, but there’s no harm in letting a coach leave his own back yard wearing a golf shirt with a school logo on it.
