If the latest salvo from the Porta Bella people doesn’t give the City Council good cause to pull the plug on the company’s coveted 996-acre , 2, 911-home development, then it’s hard to imagine what will.
The Signal Wednesday reported that the owners of the polluted land in the middle of Santa Clarita threatened to deny city workers access to their property where the cross-valley connector is under construction.
With much pomposity, the landowner’s attorney threatened future litigation unless the city caves in and changes the development agreement so the Porta Bella people can build their project in phases, before the entire site is clean.
It’s the height of ostentation from a group of speculators who violated the terms of that very same development agreement from the day they bought the property.
When Santa Clarita LLC purchased the site from defense contractor Whittaker Corp. in 1999, company officials knew they were legally bound to rid the entire property of 275 different contaminants before any development could begin. Moreover, they knew that under the terms of the 1996 development agreement, they must hold the city harmless if something explodes or people are exposed to toxic contamination.
But Santa Clarita LLC failed to cover the city under its insurance policy when it acquired the property, and there is no evidence that it has ever added the city as an “additional insured” — meaning the city can be sued, and would probably lose, if there were a mishap.
That was just the starting point of a two-year trail of bad faith on the part of Santa Clarita LLC. The company dragged its feet on the cleanup— which still hasn’t started— but it managed to rack up hundreds of thousands of dollars in unpaid debt to the state Department of Toxic Substances Control, which will monitor the eventual cleanup.
And now, the company says it can’t afford to decontaminate the land unless the city allows it to clean, develop and sell the property in phases— putting the taxpaying public at further monetary risk if construction workers or Porta Bella home buyers are injured in the process.
The threat from the Porta Bella people is an empty one. From the viewpoint of broken promises, the company doesn’t have a crutch to lean on.
It’s important to understand the weight of what was agreed in a March 1999 memorandum between the property owner and the City Council. Santa Clarita LLC said it would allow the city to push Golden Valley Road through a tiny section of Porta Bella, in exchange for the possibility of building homes in phases at some point in the future.
Much has been learned in the interim— foremost, that the groundwater beneath the property is polluted, and it can’t feasibly be cleaned if there is a phase of homes atop it. Fortunately, the March 1999 non-binding memorandum didn’t put the city on the hook to allow “phased” development.
Moreover, the city was doing a favor for the property owner by agreeing in spirit to anything at all, and did so without knowing the property owner was acting in bad faith. The city didn’t need to bend over backwards to get Golden Valley Road; if it wanted to, it could have taken the roadbed forcibly, through eminent domain.
It still can, and Santa Clarita LLC, for all its bluster, knows it.
