The Transit Mixed Concrete’s water usage estimates for the Soledad Canyon Mine project are “totally flawed,” said an environmentalist Wednesday.
Sue O’Carroll, a environmental analyst contracted by the city of Santa Clarita, said TMC’s estimates don’t include accurate analysis of water levels in the Santa Clara River.
“We know there is a problem with the portrait of the hydrological analysis,” O’Carroll said to the Transit Mixed Concrete Executive Advisory Committee on Wednesday afternoon.
O’Carroll said environmental documents produced by TMC state that only 9 percent of the surface flow will be used during the Phase I of the project, while using 16 percent during Phase II. She said the estimates aren’t correct because they omitted the three driest months of the year in their calculations.
“They don’t explain how they did it,” she said. “It took a while for us to figure (it) out.”
O’Carroll sent a 100-page report criticizing the data to the Bureau of Land Management and the Fish and Wildlife Service earlier this week. In the report, O’Carroll projected that the project would use an “average of 45.87 percent of the surface flow in this reach of the Santa Clara River during Phase I and an average of 79.22 during Phase II.”
She refuted TMC’s claim that during the dry season it would be able siphon water from the alluvial aquifer.
“TMC anticipates that water withdrawn from the aquifer during the wet season would be wholly replaced by inflow... TMC also predicts that the available water in storage in the alluvial aquifer would not be significantly reduced during the wet season,” stated TMC’s biological opinion.
There are three layers of water flow, O’Carroll explained to the group. In order to drain from the alluvial aquifer, she said, they would have to dry out the surface flow and sub-surface flow layers.
TMC spokesman Brian Mastin didn’t return The Signal’s phone call Wednesday.
“Once they draw from the alluvial aquifer, they’ve already drawn off the top two levels,” she said. “It’s hard to argue that they are not going to harm that fish.”
Since the discovery of arroyo toad eggs— a federally-protected endangered species— on the site in June, the city has launched full-scale review of TMC’s environmental documents. O’Carroll and the city have urged the BLM to reinitiate a review of all the species on the site.
The BLM is expected Monday to present a biological assessment of the effects of the project on the toad. The city has argued that the assessment should encompass more species like the unarmored three-spined stickleback, a fish found on the site, the California redlegged frog, which has been sighted in Santa Clarita canyons, and the slender-horned spineflower, a flower protected by the California Department of Fish and Game.
BLM spokeswoman Jan Bedrosian said the agency received O’Carroll’s report and will welcome any more new information the city has to give in the crafting of the report.
After its completed, the assessment will be reviewed by Fish and Wildlife for 135 days and then presented to the city and Los Angeles County officials.
Transit Mixed proposed in 1989 to mine 78 million tons of material to yield 56.1 million tons of sand and gravel. The BLM issued the company two 10-year permits.
However, Los Angeles County has to approve mining permits before TMC can begin. The county can only deny the project based on environmental reasons.
The Board of Supervisors denied the proposed project in April and told the mining giant to work with the city and county to find mitigation measures to help curb the environmental impacts.
There is a meeting scheduled before the board on Aug. 28, but in light of the recent discovery of the toad, city officials are sure the meeting will be continued until the biological assessment is reviewed.
Transit Mixed is owned by the Mexico-based Cemex Inc.
