It is a mixed blessing: The state Legislature this week is putting the finishing touches on a proposed $9.2 billion school construction bond initiative that, if put on the November ballot, could help alleviate school overcrowding in many areas of California.
But it would also cap developer fees, meaning that growing communities like Santa Clarita could be left holding the bag for the cost of new schools that are necessitated by new development.
The bond is just what the doctor ordered for the building industry, which would benefit significantly from a state-mandated limit on the amount a builder would have to pay for new schools.
The fees would initially be capped at approximately $1.93 per square foot of new home construction. Obviously, the amount of school fee would vary depending on the square footage of each new home, but suffice it to say that $1.93 per square foot doesn't come close to covering the cost of a new school.
Who closes the gap?
Taxpayers, of course — if not in the form of local school construction bonds, then in the form of statewide bonds like the one being pushed toward Gov. Pete Wilson's desk.
The developer fee cap ignores the fact that most new schools are built to serve new developments. If the residential growth did not occur, the new schools wouldn't be needed.
Certainly, there are other instances in which school needs expand, and there ought to be some state funding for those scenarios. For example, if a community's student-age population increases simply because people started having more babies, one wouldn't expect new development to meet those newly created needs. Similarly, aging school facilities eventually must be replaced with new ones, and this is a tab that could reasonably be picked up by the state's taxpayers.
But the majority of new schools are built to accommodate new housing. Take a look at the Santa Clarita Valley's development: Thankfully, as housing tracts sprout up, so do schools.
Who should pay for that? According to the state Legislature and the development industry, all taxpayers should.
Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster, prefers to think of it in terms of "helping new homebuyers." While there is some truth to that — after all, developers pass fees along to the homebuyers — there is no guarantee that a reduction in developers' school construction costs will actually equate to lower home prices. More than likely, it will help the development industry more than anyone else.
And, Runner's line of reasoning allows taxpayers throughout the state to be stuck with the tab for new schools that are needed for new homebuyers and an increasing population.
Yes, there have been situations in which developers have been abused. One California builder reportedly was forced to pay $9 per square foot of new housing — a figure that seems remarkably high — and The Newhall Land and Farming Co., in its deal with the William S. Hart Union High School District for the planned Newhall Ranch project, caved in and agreed to pay a construction fee that significantly exceeds the state standard.
The end result of that deal, of course, is that Newhall Ranch will be well-equipped when it comes to junior and senior high school facilities. But it never would have happened if developer fees were capped at $1.93 per square foot.
The solution?
In order to avoid excessive fees, a formula ought to be devised by which builders cover 100 percent of the costs — not 50 percent, not 150 percent — associated with constructing sufficient school facilities to accommodate the number of students that are projected to be generated by a given development.
This would prevent abuses of developers, new homebuyers and the state's taxpayers alike.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
