In light of what's happened over the past three weeks with former Hart High School softball coach Al Weil, it might be the right time to write an open letter about college recruiting to the parents of athletes within the valley.
Some people seem to believe that high school coaches are a big key to the process; that somehow they'll get their sons or daughters that coveted "full ride."
Certainly prep coaches are a part of the entire package. College recruiters sometimes consult them for insight on prospective recruits. But ultimately the decision on whether to sign a player for a scholarship lies with the college.
Universities and colleges do not include high school coaches on their payrolls. High school coaches are not a middle-man in the recruiting process. They don't and shouldn't act as agents.
They are merely teachers hired to prepare their teams.
So what does this have to do with the Weil situation?
A lot. Former Hart High player Vanessa Raschella claims Weil damaged her scholarship opportunity at Butler University in Indiana.
Former Hart Softball coach Al Weil [Signal File Photo]
A couple of years ago, Butler sought a leadoff batter. It contacted Raschella and invited her on a recruiting trip. Butler coach Jeryl Neff reportedly had only one scholarship left and needed someone with speed. She contacted Weil to ask about Raschella's quickness on the basepaths. Trying to be honest and forthright, Weil said Raschella wasn't fleet of foot. Hearing this assessment, the Butler coach decided not to choose Raschella.
When Raschella found out, she was understandably upset. Any 17- or 18-year-old with college aspirations would be. But what would have happened had Weil not told the truth and Butler gave Raschella the scholarship? The coach would have flown out here and discovered the right fielder wasn't Carl Lewis in a softball uniform. Neff would have viewed Weil as a liar and the next time she went looking for a recruit, she probably would have skipped Hart.
Colleges and universities, especially those on the Division I level, put thousands of dollars into their athletic programs. Sports on the big-time college level might be called amateur, but it is big business. Any recruiting mistake is magnified. One or two bad recruiting classes and the coach likely gets fired. Errors in talent assessment can't be made often.
So if a high school coach gives a false opinion on a particular player, it reflects poorly on his or her credibility. And recruiting is a very subjective endeavor anyway. It's not an exact science. Sometimes gems are found in the middle of nowhere. Sometimes a can't-miss high school prospect never pans out at the next level.
That's why parents need to stay informed about the recruiting process. If they believe their son or daughter isn't being properly recruited, most immediately blame a high school coach, especially if the athlete isn't receiving what they consider necessary playing time.
Want another word for coaches? Try scapegoats. From a parent's perspective, it's never the player's fault. It's no wonder more and more high school coaches exit the business. Today's society is about instant gratification. Who cares about anyone else, what can I gain out of this?
Al Weil was a victim of his own honesty. He tried to do what he believed right.
Oh sure, parents will blame him for cutting two popular players and playing favorites. But how many bosses or CEOs in this country are guilty of playing favorites? Only the employed ones.
It's a sad commentary that so much of high school athletics centers on college recruiting. The media is definitely guilty. We speculate about local players' chances for a scholarship all the time right here in this newsroom. Everyone in the world seems to have their own top-prospect list.
That, in itself, creates jealousies.
The popular line is: "Why is my kid not getting recruited and his is?" It's a common question asked by thousands of parents. Somewhere along the line a travel coach or private instructor has probably told their kid that he or she has the goods to be recruited. And when it doesn't happen, who does the blame go to?
The high school coach. That person simply didn't do enough to finish the job.
Have we forgotten the job description for high school coaches?
First and foremost, they are teachers. Sure, some are walk-ons who have jobs outside of academia. Secondly, they are there to get that team or group of individuals prepared for competition. They are there to instruct and guide. They are there to make decisions on who starts and who comes off the bench; who gets on the team and who gets cut.
Sometimes these decisions are not popular. But that's life. We can't agree on every decision the boss makes. It's the same in sports, especially team sports.
It's more of the same in recruiting. I don't know many high school coaches who don't go out of the way to help a student-athlete get a scholarship. Many go well above what's required.
Al Weil helped a lot of his players in this area. He tried to help Raschella, emphasizing to Neff all his player's strengths, especially Raschella's work ethic and commitment.
So the Butler situation didn't work out. Raschella could have found another path. Perhaps she needed to attend a junior college to improve certain aspects of her game. I know a lot of athletes who have gone that route and landed Division I scholarships, including former Hart High softball player Lisa Kelley and former Canyon High football player Scott Blade.
But again, everyone wants the elusive pot of gold. Everyone wants that rare sweet deal of a free education.
Unfortunately, it's a mirage for most.
* * *
David Shefter is The Signal's senior sports writer. His column appears Tuesdays and Thursdays. He can be reached at 254-8690, or via e-mail at [email protected] .
