Our community’s hospital is in trouble. That much has become obvious over the past two years. It needs our support, and it needs wise and unflinching guidance from leaders who are charged with the task of unraveling a mess that was two decades in the making.
Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on Monday, finally seeking the courts’ help in climbing out of a sea of red ink rather than dog-paddling in it.
It was inevitable.
But that’s easy to say now, and perhaps it wasn’t so easy to see a year and a half ago, when the board of directors for the Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Health Foundation yielded to pressure from hospital leadership and agreed to loan the hospital $4.3 million.
The hospital’s financial troubles are real, not imagined. The hospital has suffered many woes shared by other hospitals— cuts in Medicare reimbursements, for example— and some not shared by others, such as more than $30 million in repairs related to the 1994 earthquake.
When hospital CEO Duffy Watson departed after 23 years early in 2000, he left behind an ailing patient. James T. Yoshioka took over, served 13 months, then left. Now, Roger Seaver is the hospital’s third CEO in the past year and a half, having taken over in March.
Through all of this, the hospital has endured labor strife— including a nasty battle with the nurses’ union— and has tried to undo some of the economic damage that began to be done during the final years of Watson’s tenure.
It was during Yoshioka’s administration that the hospital looked to the foundation for at least a partial bailout. The foundation board in March 2000 approved the $4.3 million loan to help the hospital stem the tide of red ink.
The foundation is a separate legal entity, a non-profit organization that exists to raise money to fund hospital improvements. In the eyes of most community members, that means projects of a capital nature— things like emergency room expansions, new equipment and new facilities to meet the community’s ever-expanding health care needs. And to most people, this does not include operating expenses— things like salaries, paying off debts or footing the bill for executives’ country club memberships.
It’s no surprise, then, that those associated with the hospital and the foundation reacted with skepticism and even fear this week when The Signal started asking questions about the loan.
Many questions remain unanswered. For example, we do not know exactly what the loan covered. A letter from the foundation president was the only response to this question, and it only indicated that the $4.3 million was “allocated to several designated service-related endowment funds, including the newborn nursery, trauma/paramedic and medical surgery.”
It appears, though, that the funds were not allocated for the sorts of hospital improvement projects one would traditionally associate with foundation funds. After all, if the funds were targeted for typical foundation projects, it is highly unlikely the foundation would have called it a loan. It would have been a gift.
And in the end, that’s what it became.
The foundation, according to foundation President Diana Vose, has forgiven the loan to offset foundation administrative costs that, for years, had been carried on the hospital’s books. Strangely, several foundation board members were unaware the loan had been forgiven.
There remain as many questions to ask as there have been answers.
The forgiving of the loan leaves the foundation off the hospital’s creditor list. Ironically, the loan was given in the first place to help stave off a bankruptcy filing. That did not work. Had the loan not been granted, the foundation would be $4.3 million richer.
It’s unfortunate, but it’s also important to recognize that foundation board members thought they were doing what was right. It appears as if the foundation may have been misled by hospital leadership at the time, but regardless, board members thought they were protecting the best interests of this community and its hospital. We know most of them. They have nothing but the best of intentions.
Where does this leave the foundation?
It leaves the foundation facing a new challenge: To demonstrate to the community that we must all support the hospital, and that bringing improvements to the hospital is more important now than ever— a mission that can be responsibly achieved by donating to the foundation.
We’re confident that lessons have been learned— and we’re confident that the well-meaning , caring foundation board members can preserve its vital status as an entity that gives us all hope for a better future at Newhall Memorial.
