It’s the sort of phone call none of us like to receive: “Tim, this is your aunt Ginger. Nana is in the hospital.”
It was Friday morning. I was at the office, and my grandmother was giving us a scare. She’d become ill overnight, had experienced severe pain and was taken to the emergency room at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital. I went over to wait with my aunt and Nana while they were taking care of her and running tests to diagnose the problem.
Fortunately, her illness was not considered serious— and by mid-day she would be back at home, resting in relative comfort. But you never like to hear that a loved one is in the ER, because it’s so ominous-sounding . It’s too easy to envision the worst.
I’ve been to that hospital for a variety of occasions in the quarter-century that I’ve lived in the Santa Clarita Valley. I spent nine weeks there as a 10-year-old with a broken leg in traction. My wife and I had both of our children there. We rushed my son there when he broke his arm, and again when he suffered a febrile seizure.
No one really enjoys going to the hospital, but by and large, my family’s experiences with the hospital and its staff have been positive. Friday morning was no exception. The doctors and nurses of the ER were friendly and professional, and they took good care of my grandmother. I was grateful.
And, in addition to the expected apprehension one feels in such a situation, I was experiencing an acute sense of irony: At the time I got the phone call from my aunt, our news staff was working on a rather difficult story about the hospital. As I left the newsroom to go see my grandmother in the ER, someone joked that I’d better hope no one at the hospital recognized me— and that it was a good thing my grandmother’s last name is different from mine.
We broke the story on Saturday: The Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Health Foundation loaned $4.3 million to the financially troubled hospital last year, and foundation President Diana Vose says the loan has been forgiven to offset past foundation administrative costs.
It is an uncomfortable story but an important one. And in the life of a community newspaper, it seems as if a lot of the important stories are indeed uncomfortable, because of the nature of our role in the community.
We live here. We interact with the local leaders on a professional and personal basis. Many of our staff members are also volunteers for various local causes. We believe that being a community newspaper means not only covering the news, but also taking an active role in our hometown, and working to make it a better place.
Sometimes, those roles bump up against the news, and you can end up in the position we were in: We became aware of the foundation’s loan to the hospital, which was out of the normal scope of the foundation’s fund-raising and spending habits. It’s a news story, no doubt— but one that not everyone wants reported.
Understandably, some people involved in the story were worried about how it would look, and they were concerned about how the newspaper would handle it. They were worried about how the story will affect the foundation’s ability to raise money— an all-important task when you consider the fact that our community hospital is in financial trouble and has legitimate facility improvement needs.
And those worried board members and foundation officials? Well, I consider a lot of them to be friends.
“Remember, we’re all partners in this community,” one board member implored while in the process of questioning whether it would be advisable to publish the story.
Certainly, the story makes things difficult on the foundation, for a while. And if our roles were reversed, I’d probably be making the same arguments they made against the story. I’d probably go into “cover my butt” mode just like they did. They want what’s best for the community and the hospital, and that means a healthy hospital foundation that succeeds in generating funds to improve the hospital.
Unfortunately, in this case those fund-raising efforts went not to long-term improvements, but to buy time for a hospital that was trying unsuccessfully to avoid a bankruptcy filing. There will be people who are perturbed by that. They’ll feel as if dollars that could have been preserved for capital improvement were sacrificed in a vain attempt to stave off Chapter 11.
My friend the board member was right: We are all partners in this community, and as in many partnerships, different partners have different duties. One of the newspaper’s duties is to tell our community about events and happenings that matter to all of us, even when it’s “uncomfortable.” And when our hospital and its fund-raising foundation are enduring financial turmoil, it does matter to all of us.
We may not all agree on the story— and it seems as if those involved don’t even agree on exactly what happened— but, like the hospital foundation board members who authorized that loan, we at the paper have done what we believe is the right thing.
As a community, we all have a stake in the hospital. We need to maintain the confidence that when one of those dreaded phone calls comes— and a loved one has been taken to the community hospital— they will receive the best possible treatment from caring professionals who have the facilities and equipment necessary to do the job.
That’s how I’ve always viewed Newhall Memorial, and the fact that we’re asking tough questions about financial decisions doesn’t change that feeling one bit. Those questions, in turn, shouldn’t change our community benefactors’ philosophy when it comes to stepping up and contributing to the betterment of the hospital. It’s important, and it would be sad to see those fund-raising efforts diminish as a result of a loan decision gone awry.
The one belief we all seem to share is that Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital is one of this community’s most important institutions. Even in the midst of controversy and bankruptcy court proceedings, the community can’t afford to lose sight of that.
It is, quite literally, a matter of life and death.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
