I'm not so naive that I don't recognize the way things are done: One political group puts out a negative mailer attacking an incumbent candidate, and members of the opposing political group talk about it privately and devise a plan on how to circle the wagons.
They privately solicit contributions to a political organization, perhaps misleading the contributors just a little bit about exactly how the money will be spent, then, hiding behind the name of the organization, they put out a hit mailer attacking their foe.
That's just politics. That's how it's done these days. That's what happened with the IQ pac, the Southern California Taxpayers Alliance and the campaigns of four City Council candidates in the April 14 election: The IQ pac-backed Marsha McLean and the alliance-backed Frank Ferry, Jo Anne Darcy and Cameron Smyth.
And I don't like it.
There are some who would view a community newspaper editor's complaint about such a scenario as the musings of a political doe in the woods. Heh heh, he obviously doesn't know how it REALLY works, does he ...
Well, that's not true. I do know. I just think it's our responsibility -- as the local watchdog of the political process -- to pound the desk and say, "Dammit, that may be the way it is, but it's not the way it SHOULD be."
Thus, my aggravation with all the secrecy surrounding the alliance, its hit mailer and the group of residents who complained about it to the state Fair Political Practices Commission.
There is fault to be found all over the place, but the bottom line is the various activists, consultants and other political animals who are involved can look at you with a big manure-eating grin and deny knowledge of the whole thing because they're allowed to.
These political organizations -- like the alliance and, on a more amateurish scale, the IQ pac -- pop up all over the place as a means of allowing bigger money to flow into campaigns, avoiding individual campaign contribution limits, and to allow the actual decision-makers and composers of hit pieces to stay in the shadows.
They also allow candidates all over the place to remain intentionally ignorant of such goings-on. There's a lot of winking and nudging happening. The candidates, thus shielded from the dirty work, reap the benefits. And the outcomes of elections are shaped by people who exert power and influence without attaching their names to the effort. The law requires such groups to report the names and other information on financial contributors. In that sense, it's generally effective; following the money trail is usually a pretty good way of figuring out what makes this or that political movement tick.
But take a case like that of the alliance: Its contributors complain they didn't realize their money would be used for a negative hit mailer attacking McLean, and the few people whose names are associated with it -- political consultant Armando Azarloza, for one -- won't give up the goods when it comes to questions about who put together the hit piece, who makes the alliance's decisions, etc.
Then, after the election, some of the biggest sour grapes in town get together and file a complaint with the FPPC. For the most part, they get to remain anonymous, too, since such FPPC complaints aren't considered public records -- at least not until the FPPC decides its investigation is complete.
So, you have two sides of a battle, throwing mud at each other and hiding from public disclosure. It's maddening. If you're going to throw mud, show a little nerve. Sign your name to it.
Ironically, I generally liked the candidates the alliance supported, and although I have no real complaints about the election outcome, I was disappointed when Smyth didn't win one of the three seats.
So far, there is no proof that any of the candidates had direct prior knowledge of the alliance's specific plans. The system is set up, after all, to allow that. I hate to see these kinds of tactics being employed in my hometown. I think public elections ought to be completely fought and won in public, and I think everyone who participates should have the guts to be identified.
But as we've seen, that's not the case; you can hide behind a fence, throw rocks at your foes and run. I know it's the way it is. But dammit, it shouldn't be.
* * *
Tim Whyte is managing editor of The Signal. His commentary appears on Sundays.
