March 12, 1928, 11:57 p.m., the moment historians believe the St. Francis Dam failed and unleashed a thundering wall of water, a liquid wall of death 165-180 feet high that roiled down San Francisquito Canyon to the ocean, more than 40 miles away.
It swept the land bare and took with it at least 470 men, women and children. While the true death toll will never be known, it might have exceeded 1,000. In California's history, only the 1906 San Francisco earthquake cost more lives.
On March 10, nearly 71 years after that devastating night, 125 seventh-graders from the La Mesa Junior High Explorers team were swept back into history, to the site of the St. Francis Dam disaster.
Bill Johnson, history teacher at La Mesa Junior High, had long been intrigued by the disaster and three years ago proposed the field trip idea to his colleagues.
What developed is an interdisciplinary experience of science, math, history and composition. "We based each of our stations on the different elements of fiction, character, setting and plot," said English teacher Monica Berger.
The team of teachers, Johnson, Berger, math teacher Cindy Rice and science teacher Dave Tolle, agree the exercise in hands-on history is an important educational experience; it is also personally fulfilling. "This is something we created, and to see it unfold, to see what the students gain from it is very rewarding," Berger said.
Johnson feels the impact of being at the site of the disaster leaves a lasting impression. "There is a real emotional connection to the fact that you are able to teach at the location," he said.
After the winding bus trip up San Francisquito Canyon Road, the students are divided into four groups and accompanied either their history, science, math or English teacher to the appropriate station scattered at various locations in the canyon.
Many of the students are already well-versed in the history of the disaster. "The thing that surprises me the most is that they found Leona (the damkeeper, Tony Harnischfeger's wife), they found her body nearest the dam, but they haven't found Tony or the baby," said seventh grader Krystal Evans of Canyon Country.
Johnson's students hike up a steep brushy hillside. "Touch the lucky dam piece; it's tradition," he shouts to the students as they pass a large, broken chunk of the doomed structure on their scramble up the slope.
Two hundred feet above the canyon floor, students perch among the shattered wreckage of concrete aggregate, all that remains of the west wing-dike. They listen to Johnson's tale of events leading to the dam's collapse.
This is not a simple sightseeing field trip. Students must complete a 30-page workbook the teachers created. At Johnson's station, students work diligently filling out a plot triangle containing an historical timeline of the disaster.
Johnson recount the familiar history: Harnischfeger, the damkeeper, reports to William Mulholland that dirty water is leaking from the dam; Mulholland visits the leaking dam, declares it sound; Ace Hopewell, riding by on his motorcycle, feels a large vibration and hears crashing behind him shortly after he passes over the dam at approximately 11:55 p.m.; the dam collapses at 11:57:30 p.m.
The drama of Johnson's narrative is interrupted by a message on a walkie-talkie that it is time for the students to move on to their next station.
The trip down the mountainside to Tolle's science station is perhaps the day's most exciting event. Students gingerly make their way down the extremely steep slope in groups of three. At the steepest part of the descent is a knotted rope the teachers have installed just this year. "We haven't had any injuries on this field trip in the last two years and we're trying to keep it that way, " Tolle said. Several students slide down at least a part of the hill on their behinds.
"The best part of the trip was sliding down the hills and getting poked with the yucca plants," said Victor Anaya of Canyon Country.
As the students gather at Tolle's station in a narrow canyon, just off San Francisquito Road, Tolle reminds the students to be sensitive to the native plant life. "Remember, this is different from your backyard at home, we're in nature's back yard, if a plant is destroyed here there isn't going to be anyone around to plant a new one, so we need to be careful," he said.
After a group lesson on identifying the indigenous plant life, the students roam about the canyon working to identify the 14 numbered plants Tolle has selected.
A small cluster of students debate whether a low bush is Coyote Brush or Sugarbush.
Tolle enjoys seeing his students have the rare opportunity to do "real science" in the field. "It is a great experience for the students to be able to see what real biologists are out there actually doing," he said.
Student Drew Aresca, of Valencia, agreed: "This part of the trip is the best, learning what the different plants are," he said.
Across the road, Berger's English station is perched atop the mound of rubble left behind after the dam's center section was dynamited. "They didn't want a 200-foot piece of concrete sticking up into the sky, it would have been a constant reminder of what had happened here," she tells the silent students.
Berger's students are writing journal entries on how various players in the disaster felt at specific moments during the day and night of March 12, 1928.
The students are encouraged to stretch their imaginations to write how Harnischfeger, the damkeeper, felt after Mulholland came to inspect the dam, then, declaring the dam safe, left. Another writing assignment has the students use their descriptive powers to write an essay on what the dam looked like "as it stood in the moonlight."
Berger recounts the story of Lillian Curtis, who escaped the flood with her 2-year-old son, but whose husband and two daughters died in the deluge. She asks the students to write as if they were Curtis and "describe the panic you felt as you and your son ran up the hill to escape the flood."
Other entries ask the students to describe how Mulholland felt after the disaster and requests students to write their own perspective of the tragedy.
Students are encouraged to use their art skills in creating cover art for their dam booklets. "They have to draw a picture of the dam and the natural environment before it broke and on the back they have to draw a picture of the dam after it broke," Berger said.
Perched on a small rock, not far from the students engaged in their creative writing exercise, Karen Jameson of Valencia was enthusiastic about the trip. "I think it is a really wonderful experience, because it allows the kids to have a hands-on experience, to actually see where it happened, to touch the plants and to get a feel for the enormity of the disaster," she said.
Jameson, a Peachland Elementary school teacher, accompanied her daughter Elizabeth on the trip. "I've lived here since 1985 and never heard of the St. Francis dam until my daughter asked me to come on this trip and see what they were doing. It is really nice to see how the teachers created an interdisciplinary approach, I have been learning along with my daughter," she said.
Down the road, under the coolness of a spreading oak tree about 100 feet from where the dam collapsed, math teacher Rice is showing students how to plot points on a map. Each major player in the dam disaster — Mulholland, Curtis, Harnischfeger, Hopewell and others — are located on a map of the dam and its reservoir drawn to scale.
Another student-created map shows the path the flood took as it rushed down the Santa Clara riverbed and out to sea near Ventura. Students plot the path of destruction through Castaic Junction, Santa Paula, Fillmore and Ventura. Rice has the students estimate where their own homes stand, as well as the junior high school, in an effort to bring a sense of the disaster closer to home.
Math is incorporated into the field trip as the students struggle to understand how much water was stored in the 11.7-billion gallon reservoir. Rice has the students work out how many 500-gallon swimming pools, 50-gallon bathtubs and 5-gallon toilet flushes the reservoir contained.
The students clamor for Rice's attention as she works her way around the makeshift classroom with students perched in the tree, on boulders or sitting on a carpet of leaves.
The numbers the students have calculated are still enormous. The amount of water in the St. Francis Dam reservoir would have filled 23,400,000 swimming pools, 234 million bathtubs and flushed 2.34 billion toilets.
As the field trip ends, it wins raves from the student participants. "I really liked the field trip even though I've been poked a couple of times in my legs and derriere by the yuccas, that's what Mr. Tolle calls them," said John Ogle of Canyon Country.
"It is exhausting, but it's fun," said Jamie Flaschner of Canyon Country.
Kirk Chambers of Canyon Country said he enjoyed hiking up the hill and seeing the paleo megaslide, but also felt sad for the people who were killed in the disaster. "They had no warning and no time to react," he said.
The disaster also left an impact on Bryan Downing of Valencia. "It's just amazing that when the dam broke so many people died. I don't think people should even be living in canyons," he said.
