Santa Clarita gasoline dealers are disputing figures released last week by the Automobile Club of Southern California showing SCV residents were paying some of the highest pump prices in the nation in mid-January.
According to the Auto Club survey, Santa Claritans paid an average of $1.4990 for mid-grade 89-octane fuel, the highest price in the continental United States, while prices for 87- and 92-octane were third-highest at $1.2885 and $1.4686 respectively.
Data were gathered Jan. 14 through 18 by OPIS Energy Group, aka Oil Price Information Service, for the Auto Club's monthly Fuel Gauge Report.
Jeffrey Spring, spokesman for the Auto Club, said Wednesday that OPIS stands by its figures — even though fewer than 10 SCV gas stations were sampled.
"They are standing by those numbers as being statistically valid," said Spring, who confirmed that the sampling reflected gas prices in the 91321, 91350, 91351 and 91355 zip codes. In future months the survey will also include the 91354 zip code, he said.
The exact number and locations of gas stations were proprietary information and not revealed by OPIS to the Auto Club, Spring said.
SCV gas dealers are wondering where those stations are, because they can't find any with prices that high.
"All the dealers are definitely questioning (the numbers)," said Randy Cressall, owner of Valencia Chevron Auto Spa on Valencia Boulevard. "The first thing everyone said was, where in the world are these numbers coming from? We're always out there price-shopping our competitors, and we never knew anyone in the $1.40s, let alone $1.49 (for mid-grade gasoline)."
Cressall conducted two separate surveys of SCV gas stations and came up with averages that varied dramatically from the Auto Club numbers.
In one survey, 13 gasoline dealers from Valencia, Saugus, Newhall and Canyon Country voluntarily responded to a questionnaire about their prices on the dates the Auto Club survey was conducted.
The average price for 87-octane fuel among the 13 dealers was $1.2036, compared to the Auto Club's $1.2885. Mid-grade 89-octane fuel averaged $1.3128, compared to $1.4990, and premium 92-octane fuel averaged $1.4082, compared to $1.4686.
Cressall and his employees also surveyed current gas prices Tuesday and Wednesday at 28 stations throughout the SCV, visually observing prices at every local station except Sand Canyon and Castaic. (Castaic was not included in the Auto Club survey.)
Regular unleaded 87-octane fuel averaged $1.2176 this week, mid-grade 89-octane fuel averaged $1.3315 and premium 92-octane fuel averaged $1.4265. Among the 28 stations, mid-grade gasoline ranged from $1.2390 to a high of $1.3990 — 10 cents cheaper than the $1.4990 average reported by the Auto Club.
Cressall said he is concerned about the accuracy of the Auto Club survey because of the way it affects consumer buying decisions.
"I know it will have an effect on my business and other dealers because it will be a reason for people to buy gas over the hill," Cressall said. "If they're down there they are going to go out of their way to buy gas down there."
