The production company who followed detectives into the home of Sandi Nieves last July and captured footage of the subsequent investigation was granted another stay by the District Court of Appeals Monday, meaning it will not have to turn over the videotapes to the defense — for now.
The decision came days after Superior Court Judge Ronald Cohen denied the request made by Maxwell Productions to withhold the footage taken for the 12-part Arts & Entertainment television series "L.A. Detectives."
Nieves is facing four counts of murder, one of attempted murder and one of arson after allegedly killing her four daughters and trying to kill her son and burn down her house on Cherry Creek Drive July 1.
Deputy Public Defender Howard Waco said he has heard the videotapes contain footage of authorities saying they wanted to delay possible discovery matters and to prevent Nieves from talking to her 14-year-old son David, who lives with his father in Riverside.
"(The detectives) never expected that the tape would be disclosed so they made many statements to the A&E people of a very candid nature," Waco said.
In December, County Commissioner Gerald T. Richardson said he would not preside over the preliminary hearing because he had been "tainted" after watching the videotapes.
Richardson said he was "greatly concerned" about what he saw on the videotapes, explaining he felt they indicated "a plan, a scheme, a devise, by the Sheriff's Department that Mr. Waco or his investigator never speak to (Nieves' son David)."
Deputy District Attorney Ken Barshop continues to make the claim that David does not want anything to do with his mother and that he has even gone so far as to change his phone number.
Sheriff's officials told The Signal in December that the production company, in exchange for being allowed access to the home and the details of the ensuing investigation, relinquished editorial control over the material and the Sheriff's Department had first edit rights on anything they do.
"At this point, the Court of Appeals has it and they can decide to do a number of things," said Terri Towery of the appellate department of the public defenders office.
Towery said The District Court of Appeals, which granted the stay while it reviews Maxwell Productions' appeal, can either make an immediate decision about the release of the tapes or order a hearing with oral arguments.
She said the most common result in these cases is for the court of appeals to simply deny the request without a hearing, but a hearing may be granted "if they think that there may be merit to (the petition)."
"You never know," Towery said.
"Until (the tape situation) is resolved, basically the case is in hiatus," Barshop said. "We're coming back (Feb. 16) to see where we are."
