ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

School bond heads for ballot

It's affectionately known as "tidal wave two" — the swell of close to 300,000 students expected to fill California's classrooms over the next five years.

While California lawmakers continue to put more and more money into schools, it has not been enough. Overcrowding and dilapidated buildings are already plaguing school districts and the problem is not expected to improve anytime soon. Funds coming from the state go toward teacher salaries and supplies, and not toward the growing crisis at hand.

A bond measure on the Nov. 3 ballot could provide many of those schools — including a few of Santa Clarita's — with money needed to remedy some of those problems. Proposition 1A is the state's largest bond initiative at $9.2 billion. If approved by voters, the bond would allot $6.7 billion to K-12 schools and $2.5 billion to state colleges and universities specifically for construction and modernization projects.

No one denies the money is needed. However, some controversy has surrounded the current bond since it was in the state legislature. The controversy covers two areas: caps on the fees developers pay for school construction projects, and a 50/50 match program in which local school districts would have to pay half the cost of school construction. The ultimate decision on the matter is now in the hands of the voters.

What are bonds?

Chuck Nicol, a principal analyst for the state's Legislative Analyst's Office, a nonpartisan office providing fiscal and policy analysis to the state legislature, said bonds are similar to taking a mortgage out on a house.

"The state borrows money by selling bonds to investors," Nicol said.

In the case of general obligation bonds, the state treasurer sells bonds which are exempt from both state and federal income tax. For that reason, Nicol said, bonds are an attractive investment, usually to investors in higher tax brackets.

The money and interest are then paid back using the state's General Fund, which comes from personal and corporate income tax and state sales tax. Nicol said it has generally taken the state 20 to 30 years to pay back a bond.

Currently, schools already receive large amounts of money from the state. Proposition 98 set a minimum amount the state must set aside for its schools, and this year Gov. Pete Wilson appropriated $500 million over that set amount.

Bonds and developer fees have been other ways schools have received funds. There are two types of bonds schools can potentially receive money from: local general obligation bonds and special local bonds known as Mello-Roos bonds.

Local general obligation bonds are similar to the state's general obligation bonds, but are sold locally and must receive a two-thirds majority voter approval, instead of a simple majority. The bonds are paid off by taxes levied on property in the district.

Mello-Roos are similar to general obligation bonds but smaller, special districts which don't have to encompass the complete school district, are asked to vote on the measure. Many times they encompass specific developments within a community. The bonds are paid off by charges assessed to property owners within the special district, according to the LAO.

Fiscal Impact

The state's Legislative Analyst's Office recently released its findings on the bond's impact. It found there is a need for more schools and modernization if estimates made by the state Department of Finance are accurate.

The department estimated the number of students in California will increase by 300,000 over the next five years. Billions of dollars will be needed to handle the demand for new and improved schools.

As of July 1998, the LAO found $2.9 billion in state funding for land and new buildings had been requested by the state's school districts. Applications for modernization funds also totaled $2.9 billion.

The report establishes there is a need. If the bond is approved by voters, the LAO found that the state would be obligated to not only pay the amount of the bond, but also the principle. The state typically pays bonds and their interest off over a period of 25 years.

The LAO estimates that if the bond is sold at an interest rate of 5 percent, the total cost would ultimately total $15.2 billion — $9.6 billion for principal and $5.6 billion for interest. The state would have to pay an average of $600 million a year from the General Fund to pay back the bond.

Analyst Nicol said passage of the bond, however, would not drive California into deep indebtedness and that many other states owe much more.

"I wouldn't say we're borrowing too much," he said.

California also may be able to get a better interest rate than it has in the past. The state's recent budget surplus and economic upswing have played a major role in raising its credit rating by the country's three major investment firms.

Proposition 1A

Proposition 1A is known as the Class Size Reduction Kindergarten-University Public Education Facilities Bond Act of 1998. The $9.2 billion bond would be broken down with $6.7 billion allocated for K-12 schools and $2.5 billion for higher education facilities.

Of the K-12 funds, $2.9 billion would go toward construction of new schools; $2.1 would go toward modernization; $700 million toward class reduction programs; and up to $1 billion for hardship districts. The state would determine if the district is unable for financial reasons to provide sufficient local matching funds or will incur excessive school construction costs that are beyond the control of the district.

Funds for construction will be given on a 50/50 match program with developers required to pay half of the construction and the state paying the other half. To qualify, districts must meet one of four requirements, until the year 2000 when they would be required to meet two. Those include: 30% of the district's pupils must be on a multi-track, year-round program; the district has placed a local general obligation bond on the ballot and received over 50% of the vote; the district has issued a local obligation bond to at least 15% of the district's bonding capacity; and 20% of the district's classrooms are portables.

If the state runs out of money, the districts would be allowed to collect 100 percent of the school construction cost from the developer. When money becomes available through the state, the developer could be reimbursed.

Modernization programs, would be on an 80/20 match with the state paying for 80 percent of the modernization and 20 percent paid locally. The state presently pays close to 100 percent of the cost.

Districts would be given the flexibility to use state, local or private architects, and would be allowed to used wrap up insurance. Local districts would be able keep savings if school a construction project is completed under-budget.

Developer fees would be capped at $1.93 per square foot. School districts have been able to negotiate higher fees thus far. Construction projects could not be denied if a builder mitigates under Proposition 1A's provisions. The court decisions which had established these current abilities, known as the Mira, Hart, Murrietta decisions, would be suspended for 8 years.

Santa Clarita Schools

Since 1986, state voters have approved $8.8 billion in general obligation bonds for K-12 school construction and modernization. The Legislative Analyst's Office found as of July 1998, $70 million of that money was left, but the money has already been delegated.

Each of the Santa Clarita Valley's school districts have already been approved for funds and are awaiting Prop. 1A or another bond to get those funds.

With hundreds of thousands expected to flood the state over the next five years, the valley's districts are bracing for an influx of students. Portables, teachers with shopping carts, multi-track classrooms, and run-down buildings are all problems facing each of the valley's districts.

Dr. Marc Winger, superintendent of the Newhall School District, said his district has been awaiting modernization funds. Approximately $1.1 million for a project at Wiley Canyon has already been approved, he said. The district is dealing with overcrowding by implementing a multi-track, year round program at six of its seven schools. There are currently 6,050 students in the district.

In the William S. Hart Union High School District there are currently four junior high schools and six high schools. The schools combined are designed to handle 10,131 according to the district.

As of Oct.1, the total number of students enrolled in the district was 14,124 and is projected to reach 21,458 by the year 2000.

The Hart District, Sulphur Springs Union School District and the Saugus Union School District are also seeking funds. Saugus was approved earlier this year for its Plum Canyon project and is awaiting money.

So Why the Controversy?

Like many issues, there are two schools of thought on Proposition 1A. While neither disagrees schools need money and that this bond would supply that money, there is some trepidation about endorsing it.

On one side are the prop's backers: builders and contractors, such as the Association of Builders and Contractors; unions, such as the California Federation of Labor, AFL-CIO; various university and Cal State University alumni associations and the California Teachers Association. On the other hand, there are those who have taken an a stand against the proposition and those who are neutral, not sure of which way the vote should go.

Before it made it to the ballot, the bond measure hit snags in both the Assembly and the Senate. The original was a $9 billion bond which was killed by Assembly members because it did not contain caps on the fees developers pay for school construction. The second time around, the revamped $9.2 billion bond contained the caps sought by many Assembly Republicans, but almost did not pass the Senate. The Senate did approve it, Wilson signed it and it now lays before voters.

Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster, and Senator William J. "Pete" Knight, R-Palmdale, both of whose districts include the Santa Clarita Valley, voted for the bond measure while on the floor of their houses in Sacramento. Runner said although he voted for the measure, he believed it was not the best way to get schools built.

"I voted to put it on the ballot and let the people decide," he said.

As for the cap on developers' fees, Runner has stated that he does not see it as much of a controversy. Schools will still be built and must meet a state standard, so the quality will not diminish.

"I believe school construction is far more expensive than it needs to be," Runner said.

In some cases, he cited, developers have paid as high as $9 per square foot for school construction. Developers often pass that cost along to the homebuyers.

Yes on 1A campaign spokesman Bill Houck, president of the California Business Roundtable, agreed the issue is not as hotly contested as portrayed. "I don't think there's a real concern there," he said.

Houck said the fact that school districts would have to pay half of the school's construction is the real issue. If passed, developers would not have to cover the half of the costs as before, therefore requiring the district to fill in the gap.

Passing local bonds would help supplement a district's money, he said. Runner also agreed that local districts need to get more involved in funding construction in their districts, in both new and modernization projects.

"Anything we can move from the state to local control, I'm glad to do that," Runner said.

Those in local school districts say that is not as easy as it sounds. Newhall Superintendent Winger said if passed, his district would be required to come up with 20 percent of modernization money. Passing local general obligation bonds would have to be looked at seriously to get that money, but doing so has traditionally been a tough task. Passing such a bond requires a two-thirds majority vote, not a simple majority as many would like.

Gary Schamber, a Stevenson Ranch Town Council member, said he was also worried that districts would have to resort to passing local bonds.

"We're in trouble here because we're not going to get a local bond passed," he said.

Winger said the Newhall District, which includes Stevenson Ranch, tried twice to pass a bond in 1990, but failed both times. The district is looking at another local bond as a means to raise more money for its schools. Voters, he believes, don't vote for local bonds many times because the money comes from their property taxes. Homeowners get their tax statement and see the money on there that goes to pay the bond.

When the state passes a general election bond, homeowners are still paying for that bond but through their income tax money that is put into state coffers. Voters, then, do not directly see the amount of money taken from them, so voting for a statewide bond is more likely, he said. The fact is, however, they are still paying as much, and to schools not in their district, Winger said. Local bonds send money to local schools.

Winger said while the bond does contain a mixed bag of offerings, the Newhall District has taken a neutral position. "There is probably some money for us," he said, referring to the money already approved for some of the district's modernization plans. "I think a lot was given away."

Robert Lee, William S. Hart Union School District superintendent, agreed.

"I think the dollar bill has had a significant influence in the opinion of legislators and the bills they present and laws they make," Lee said.

Lee too was not sure how to urge voters to cast their votes. He knows how badly schools need money, including those in his own district, and he has fought hard to make that happen. In 1996, Lee was instrumental in forming the Coalition for Suitable School Facilities Funding. The purpose of the group was to inform over 100 school district throughout the state about threats to the Mira, Hart, Murrietta court cases which allowed districts to negotiate higher fees from developers.

"There's no question by the educational coalition, the school and by the developers and community that a major bond is needed and would be supported," he said. "The issue was how clean of a bond would it be."

Lee had credited the passage of the bond through the legislature to lobbying from developers and builders.

A majority of those supporting the Yes on 1A campaign are businesses, developers and builders.

"It's hard to say, 'Go vote for the proposition' because there's so much hanging on it," he said.

College of the Canyons could also benefit from construction and modernization funds if the bond passes. Like many other college campuses, community college enrollment is expected to jump from 1.48 million to 1.81 million in the next 10 years. COC is already overcrowded.

Unlike many of her grammar and high school colleagues, COC President Dianne Van Hook is urging the state's voters to support the bill. Van Hook said the school is expecting $25-30 million over the next four years, if passed. With $12-14 million of the money if they receive it, she said, the school would construct a performing arts center. Other improvements would include a fire safety access road, and music and dance lab.

But school districts have not been the only ones concerned over the 8-year repeal of the court decisions.

Assemblyman Tom McClintock, R-Northridge, has spoken out against the bond. Fiscally, he said, it is bad for the state, adding $2,000 of new debt obligation to every family in the state.

"Bonds are the state's MasterCard," McClintock said.

The state runs up charges and has to pay it back plus interest, through taxes. Residents will be paying $100 in extra taxes over the next 20 years if the bond is passed, he said. The bond's size is frightening, he said. It is three times larger than all of the bonds passed in the state since 1982.

"The real tragedy is the state had a surplus," he said.

The $4.4 billion surplus from the recent state budget could have gone toward construction. Taxpayers would have saved money also, he said.

McClintock said he would rather see a pay as you go system and local bonds to pay for construction. And why not, he said, the two systems adequately funded schools in the 50's and 60's during the babyboom era when the population was growing twice as fast as it is today. Local bonds should be supported because the money that goes into them from the taxpayer, goes directly to the local schools, and nowhere else, he said.

Funds from general obligation bonds, such as Prop. 1A, go to whatever school has priority on the list.

"It would be the responsible thing for districts to float local bonds," McClintock said.

City leaders in Santa Clarita, as well as around the state, are also upset over what would happen if the decisions were repealed. Under the repeal, city leaders would lose their ability to deny a new development if they felt the developer did not adequately mitigate the impacts with the school district. Santa Clarita Mayor Jan Heidt expressed her concern over the issue earlier this year in a letter to legislative representatives.

The League of California Cities has been at the head of the No on Prop 1A campaign. League spokesman Dan Carrigg said city leaders want to be sure the impacts of any developments are mitigated.

"We want to protect our school facilities," Carrigg said. "That's really the core issue."

Everyone has some definite views on the issue. Yes on 1A spokesman Houck said he agrees the bill has some controversial points, but believes voters should choose the measure because "the future of California is in its young people."

"If we're going to properly educate children, we've got to have proper facilities for them," Houck said, a point all sides agree with.

State legislators and groups on all sides of the issue have now put the decision into the hands of the voters who will now have to weigh the issues and decide for themselves.

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/main/1198/110198m.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 3,019 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:v2_datefile_main
  • text:valley_names [12 distinct/25 mentions: Santa Clarita, Saugus, Newhall, Stevenson Ranch, College of the Canyons, COC, William S. Hart, Sulphur Springs]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By ALECIA FOSTER]
  • text:valley_elected_official “George Runner”, “Knight, R-”
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 9, national 1