Few people argue that the public education needs to change. However, whether or not Proposition 8 can plug the holes in California's leaky school system is the center of an ongoing debate.
On November 3, voters will decide whether to pass the "Permanent Class Size Reduction and Educational Opportunities Act of 1998," also known as Prop. 8, or put it in dry dock.
If passed, permanent class-size reduction in grades K-3, a tougher drug policy, an office of the Chief Inspector, school-site councils and a different credentialing process for teachers all become state law.
"The truth is public education is erratic and it's as good as it's ever been in our schools. We have a lot of kids being short-changed," said Governor Pete Wilson.
Wilson's backing Prop. 8, along with the California Republican Party, California Federation of Republican Women, California State Sheriff's Association, California District Attorneys Association, the California Business Roundtable and others.
But unanswered questions about the Office of the Chief Inspector and school-site councils united the California State PTA, California School Board Association, California Democratic Party, League of Women Voters, the California Federation of Teachers and teacher groups to urge voters to say no.
Opposition centers around the inspectors office. Without Senate approval or public vote, the governor appoints the inspector for a 10-year term. There's no limit on the inspector's or staff salaries. To fire a poorly performing inspector, agreement by 80 percent of the state legislature is required.
"Prop 8 is too hard to change if something goes wrong," said "No on Prop. 8" spokesman Nick DeLuca. "Can you imagine trying to get 80 percent of the state legislature, plus the governor to agree on anything other than apple pie?"
The difficult firing process raises local eyebrows, too. Michael von Buelow, assistant superintendent of personnel for the William S. Hart Union High School District, calls the measure unnecessary, redundant and fraught with potential problems, particularly the inspector's office.
"It's unprecedented," he said. "There's no confirmation process and the danger exists of abuse. If the governor selects a special interest person, it might skew school programs or performance."
Once hired, the chief inspector ranks and records information on academic achievement, test scores, drop out and graduation rates for 8,000 California schools. Traditionally, the State Department of Education collected the data from local districts, a job Prop. 8 supporters claim isn't being done.
"The department of education isn't accountable for data in our schools," said Mitch Zak of the Yes campaign. "Data is flying around and nobody is collecting it effectively."
Even Bill Lucia, an executive from the State Department of Education, acknowledges departmental woes. "The work isn't done well or timely," he said. "We still don't know precisely where we are and without the right information, how do we know what districts need help?"
Help comes in various forms, but specifically in dollars. Since 1991, California spent $270 billion on public schools. With so much money funneling into classrooms, Zak wants to know why student test scores fall below the national average. "In 43 categories, California students were below average in 28 of them." he said.
From Lucia's seat, in the heart of state education, the complaint's the same. "Over 50-percent of college freshman have to take remedial language skills in college. And these are kids supposedly in the top one-third of their high school class."
The message Lucia heard from state colleges was loud and clear. "The output and quality of the K-12 system is down." he said.
Resurrecting quality in the classroom isn't cheap; the inspectors office is expected to need $15-20 million annually. Paying for the inspector's office via Prop 8 means dipping into funds from the State Department of Education's $200 million operating budget.
As Lucia explained, education has two different budgets: one used to fund the State Department of Education in Sacramento, and another used for classrooms.
School district money comes from Prop 98 in the late 1980's, a classroom's biggest benefactor. The bill promised 40 percent of California's revenue for education. In 1998, 40-percent meant $35 billion came through the State Department of Education before being sent to California classrooms. Federal money used to fund special education programs and programs for academically at-risk kids added an additional $3 billion.
In-house money, or money that stays in Sacramento totaled $200 million. It's from this fund that Prop. 8 supporters hope to find the money needed for the inspector's office.
"School districts will continue to get the same amount of money," said Lucia. "Sacramento will continue to get the same money."
There's no skipping over the truth that money for education must come from education. At a time when teachers complain about salary and benefits, when schools are overcrowded and struggling for seats, when computers need replacing, books need updating, and superintendents order more campus portables, does diverting money away from the State Department of Education for an inspectors office seem the state's best bet?
Instead of siphoning money from education, DeLuca wants the state to work with what they have.
"The logical answer is to tell the people we're paying now that they'll have to do it better." he said. "They already work for us, so let's go back and fine tune or put some heat under somebody."
There's better ways to spend school money according to von Buelow. His own wish list for district schools include standards development, teacher preparation programs, class-size reduction above third grade and technology guaranteed to take schools into the next millennium.
Using schools like a petri dish for untested experiments upsets DeLuca. "Look at the whole system and ask yourself. Taken as a whole, does Prop 8 make schools better or worse?" he asked.
California already has class-size reduction for grades K-3 and Prop 8 sets aside money to ensure its existence. "This program isn't in jeopardy," DeLuca said. "Nobody in California disagrees with it. Using class-size reduction is meant to sell the initiative."
Von Buelow shares a similar opinion. "Class size reduction and drug policies already exist." he said. "I think the writers of Prop 8 used them purposely to mislead."
California has a drug policy too. Prop 8 wants to remove principals' discretion in handling small drug-related issues.
DeLuca sees a fat-laden measure designed to sell buzzwords to voters. He calls the inspector's office a waste of time and says the state doesn't need another bureaucracy run by a political appointee. "Only state government would think that setting up a new bureaucratic office would solve any problem." he joked.
Tension runs just as high over Prop. 8's proposed school-site councils. If passed, every California school will have a council of parents and teachers empowered to set curriculum and spend school funds. The only requirement — consulting with the school's principal.
Hart schools use advisory councils now, von Buelow explained, but they aren't considered governing councils. "Prop 8 doesn't explain the relationship between school boards and governing councils and what happens if they're at odds in philosophy," said von Buelow.
Equally unclear is what will happen when new state-wide curriculum standards begin in 1998-99. "Students have a beacon in front of them to guide them in their development," said von Buelow. "If this goes through, there could be a billion different standards all over the map. Uniformity and common standards would be out the window."
Should a council make a mistake and take the school in the wrong direction, explained DeLuca, neither the principal nor the school board can override their authority.
"Let's try this at one school, or one district, or even one city, but not with every school all at once." said DeLuca.
As a manager of teaching professionals, Prop 8's change in teacher competency concerns von Buelow.
Currently, new teachers have two years to prove themselves competent or risk dismissal. The practice puts the onus on school officials to thoroughly screen first-year teachers. Should a substandard teacher spend two years in the profession, their job is protected by tenure.
According to Prop 8, dismissed teachers can be rerouted to other district schools, thus making it easier for a bad teacher to earn their tenure.
"This is a dance of the lemons philosophy," explained von Buelow, "shipping people around rather than dealing with the issue. It doesn't solve the problem and it's not an incentive for a principal to do their homework when deciding to move someone out of the profession or out of the district."
Despite the holes in Prop 8, DeLuca isn't entirely against it. But, he knows voting for one section means voting for them all. "When we vote, we're not voting on ideas and we're not reading into the prop.," he said. "We are creating law."
