Biological warfare, once the subject of seemingly far-fetched science fiction novels, has now become everyday conversation for many concerned Americans— including medical professionals who must now be alert for signs of bioterrorism-induced diseases.
To better equip local doctors and nurses with knowledge of such illnesses, “Bioterrorism— The Next Hot Zone, Year 2001” was presented to them on Nov. 30 by Dr. Laurene Mascola, chief of Acute Communicable Disease Unit for the Los Angeles County Dept. of Health Services.
More than 100 Santa Clarita Valley health care providers attended the informative event, held in Council Chambers at City Hall.
Featured was an overview on the threat of bioterrorism, the challenges and importance of early detection, clinical recognition of bioterrorist threats and diseases, and reporting to public health officials.
Defined as the overt or covert dispensing of biologic agents (bacterial, viral, or parasitic) to intentionally produce disease or death in a susceptible population, bioterrorist acts could range from dissemination of aerosolized anthrax spores to water or food product contamination.
“This is a new type of warfare, you need to be thinking zebras,” Mascola said.
Mascola’s four-legged reference meant this: When doctors detect “hoofbeats” — signs and symptoms that could represent a constellation of commonly seen illnesses— they must now look and listen more keenly, as they could be facing a bioterror-related disease.
Information provided was to help physicians think “out of the box” when it comes to recognizing bioterrorism-related illnesses. Such illnesses— which include inhalational, cutaneous and gastrointestinal anthrax, smallpox, viral hemorrhagic fevers, pneumonic plague and botulism— were previously low on the list of maladies doctors anticipated seeing in emergency rooms and private practice. Recent terrorist attacks have changed that picture.
Mascola explained that biological agents provide more “bang for the buck,” producing mass casualties at a low cost.
Easy to obtain and difficult to detect (are generally invisible, odorless and tasteless), they often have a delayed onset and, therefore, a delayed time between exposure and illness.
“Bioweapons are the poor man’s atomic bomb,” said Mascola, a medical doctor with a master’s degree in public health.
Such threat delivers a devastating psychological impact, causing panic and social disruption, which are also prime goals of terrorists, Mascola said.
Mascola spoke on bioterror-illnesses , including their early, progressive and late signs and symptoms, differential diagnoses (to rule out any other causes that present with similar indicators), infection control practices, the risks/benefits of vaccinations, modes of bioweapon transmission, and medical management of the diseases.
The fear factor, currently pervasive across America, need to be replaced with knowledge and common sense, Mascola said. “Without knowledge there is fear, and fear makes us incapable of responding,” she said. “The less afraid we are the more proactive and productive we can be to protect our nation’s well-being .”
Mascola noted that biowarfare is not a new adversarial tactic. Cases in point: In 1346 warring Tatars threw plague-contaminated corpses over city walls to infect the Kaffa in Ethiopia; during the French and Indian War, the British handed out smallpox-laden blankets to Natives American; during WORLD WAR I German agents infected livestock with anthrax to be fed to allied troops.
In the most significant U.S. attack prior to 9-11 , eight salad bars in Oregon were intentionally sprayed with Salmonella in 1984 and sickened more than 700 people (this was done in an attempt to manipulate a local election). In 1994 Tokyo commuters experienced a deadly attack of Sarin gas.
Mascola spoke about smallpox— and diffused a public concern about the disease that has been circulating as of late. Caused by the variola virus, smallpox infection was eliminated from the world in 1977. Its symptoms include high fever, fatigue, head and backaches and a characteristic pus-filled rash, most prominent on the face, arms, and legs. While the majority of patients with smallpox recover, death occurs in up to 30 percent of cases. Smallpox is spread from one person to another by infected saliva droplets that expose a susceptible person having face-to-face contact with the ill person.
People have been fearing a smallpox carrier will be deliberately dropped off at an airport or bus station to infect others, Mascola said. However, she believes that threat is not reasonable.
“When someone has smallpox they are just to sick to be walking around and infecting others. I don’t see this as likely at all,” she said.
Mascola did say that a bioterrorist’s probable means of disseminating smallpox or anthrax would be via an aerosolized route, such as through an aerial bomb, ballistic missile warhead or cropduster.
Despite the disturbing nature of bioweaponry, California has thus far been free of any attacks or outbreaks, Mascola said, adding that diligent surveillance by government, state and city health officials, and local medical caregivers is ongoing.
“We have been very fortunate here, but there are bad people out there,” she said. “At least 17 nations are believed to have biological weapons programs, and Iraq has acknowledged producing and weaponizing anthrax. The good news, however, is that so far they have not been used on a wide scale.”
If an outbreak was to occur, however, particularly of something like botulism which causes respiratory paralysis and requires victims to be on ventilators, it could be devastating to the entire medical system, she warned.
Also presented that day, “Los Angeles County Fire Department Perspectives on Terrorism,” with speaker Los Angeles County Fire Dept. Battalion Chief Michael Singer.
Singer described weapons of mass destruction, the role of A first responder as it pertains to the fire department, and the need for self protection when it come to encountering a possible bioweapon contamination.
Dr. Ellsworth Pryor, medical director for infection control at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital and Providence Holy Cross Hospital in Mission Hills lauded the symposium as being informative and useful for medical professionals. As Pryor specializes in the diagnosis and treatment of infectious disease, he is well-versed in much of what was delivered, but said he found it useful for the SCV medical populace. “Dr. Mascola is a very good speaker and I was impressed with her lecture, the same for Chief Singer,” said Pryor, noting that Newhall Memorial has a multi-disciplinary bioterror preparedness team.
The mission of Acute Communicable Disease Control is to prevent the spread of communicable disease in Los Angeles County. The unit is responsible for epidemiology and control of all reportable communicable diseases not managed by the other Disease Control Programs, and for investigating various outbreaks, including those caused by certain diseases that could potentially be related to possible bioterrorist activity.
While the likelihood of a large-scale bioterrorist event in Los Angeles County is currently thought to be low— given the high level of technical sophistication required to develop a weapon to disperse the biologic agents in the manner necessary to infect massive numbers of persons— Health Services is focusing its efforts on improving the ability to detect and respond to such an event, should it occur.
