I think it's important to chronicle this moment.
As I write this, outside my front door are several dozen young people mourning the death of Jerrod Miyaki, an 18-year-old kid who was killed today (Thursday). Jerrod was killed by an alleged drunk driver who was driving the wrong way on the freeway.
As I have been winding down my law practice, I've had some time to reflect on what I've been doing for the last eight years. The transition has been one from idealistic student of the law to a pragmatist who wonders how much longer society can tolerate the excesses permitted by the law.
I know I will regret what I am about to write, but it needs saying. It's the truth. I've thought about saying this for a long time, especially when I take my walks through Central Park at the memorial to the kids who have been killed by drunk and reckless drivers.
When it comes to drugs, drunk driving and traffic matters - as a lawyer - it is embarrassing what you can get away with if you're merely half awake.
This is not the fault of any one party to the system. It is a combination of factors. In Santa Clarita, we have three excellent bench officers. While they may sentence people justly, sentenced prisoners only stay in jail for about 7 percent of their term.
While we have interested prosecutors, the brass' zeal for stats results in being able to negotiate dispositions that are almost embarrassing to talk about. Once I got a kid three years' probation after he got caught with more than 59,000 hits of ecstasy, or 30 pounds of the drug. I could entertain you for hours with similar stories.
This makes the system look like a joke.
Drunk-driving penalties are little more than inconvenience. The offender picks up three years of summary probation - i.e., just keep your nose clean - does a 90-day alcohol program, has a complete restriction on driving for 30 days and has a court- and DMV-imposed restriction thereafter. That, in addition to fines (totaling about $1,400) is it.
While greater penalties are supposed to be imposed for higher blood alcohol levels, they are rarely imposed. So, the person who drives at 0.08-percent blood alcohol receives the same punishment as someone who is grossly intoxicated at, say, 0.25 percent (really drunk). Unless it's a third offense, any mandatory jail time is typically credited for the time spent during arrest and booking; or served at the leisure of the convicted.
I especially get a kick out of the driving suspension.
Attorney asks client - whose license is suspended - "How did you get to court today?"
Client: "Oh, I drove."
Second and third offenses? Probation is typically revoked and reinstated with perhaps some nominal sanction in the form of a fine or a few days' jail time, for which you'll probably be cited out the back door.
Conversely, in Germany, on a first offense, you lose your privilege to drive for a year (no driving at all). In Poland, you lose your privilege to drive for up to three years for a first offense.
Even our adjacent states impose harsher penalties. For example, in Arizona, a second DUI offense is punishable as a felony, and the minimum jail term is 120 days, reducible to 60 days pursuant to enrollment in an in-patient alcohol program. In California, a second offense typically requires a mere 96 hours of jail time.
People need to be afraid to drive drunk. They need to know that they are going to go to jail for a good, long time, and that their driving privilege will be revoked for a lengthy period.
If you kill someone while driving recklessly or driving drunk, you deserve to stand trial for murder. But somewhere in the folklore of our law, it was decided that killing by means of an automobile somehow lessened the gravity of the crime. The culture of our system has only reinforced that idea.
The bottom line is this: When the defense attorney tells you the punishment is too lenient - it's too lenient.
While some might ask how we will pay for all this reform, those people should ask the kids who are paying for it right outside my front door.
Jerrod seemed like such a good kid. I didn't speak with him all that much. But he was fundamentally a respectful kid who seemed to be upward-bound.
From what I understand, the trauma to his organs in the course of the accident killed him. It's strange to be describing Jerrod as "killed."
He was hanging out with the kids just the other night.
Anthony D. Zinnanti lives in Saugus. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
