ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Replacing Smyth: Council Must Choose

In politics as in romance, sometimes something wrong can feel oh, so right. And vice versa. Case in point: The debate over how the Santa Clarita City Council will fill the seat to be vacated by Assemblyman-elect Cameron Smyth, who is fulfilling the next step of his political destiny by becoming our newest representative in Sacramento. (Congratulations go to Cameron - he's a good egg.)

To fill his City Council seat, there are two basic options. The council can appoint someone to finish Smyth's term, scheduled to run until the April 2008 election. Or, the council can call a special election - which would cost approximately $175,000 - that would be held in June. The winner would serve just 10 months before, presumably, running for re-election as an incumbent.

The council is expected to take up the matter during its meeting Tuesday. But don't think for a second that this will be the first time the council members have discussed it.

The situation presents quite a dilemma, and there is no perfect solution to it. There's a good case to be made both for and against each option.

On one hand, a special election is the more democratic route, giving voters the opportunity actually to choose their own representative. Novel concept, eh?

It would mean the winner of the June election would have actually earned the voters' stamp of approval before running as an incumbent, rather than simply having incumbency bestowed upon him or her by the current council members.

Make no mistake: Incumbency would be an extremely valuable, and powerful, gift.

Naysayers would say the cost of the special election is a reason to appoint rather than elect, but if you put it in the overall context of the city's spending (Cemex, anyone?), $175,000 seems a small price to pay for democracy.

So, on paper, a special election seems like the best thing.

On paper.

In reality, there is a more cynical view of American politics to take into account, and that view is entirely valid. It goes like this:

The special election, if held, would bear little resemblance to an idealist view of the democratic process. The reality would be that there would be a candidate (or maybe two) who already has (have) massive finances lined up and ready to go - finances that otherwise might have been held in reserve for the regular election a year later.

With a shorter run-up to the election than normal, there would be little opportunity for an upstart candidate to gather enough steam - and money - to challenge a well-financed one who is already poised and ready to go.

The election would be over before it started, even more so than usual, and any halfway well-informed political handicapper could probably tell you today who the winner would be.

The $175,000 election would be a formality.

So here's the behind-the-scenes dilemma, if you're a council member right now:

If you call the special election, you already have a pretty good idea of who will win. Do you think that person is a good choice to represent the community - not just for a year, but potentially for several terms?

If not, and you opt for an appointment, will you base your choice on finding a good council member who might serve for the long haul, or do you try to find a "caretaker" - an experienced local leader who would serve well for a year, then refrain from seeking re-election so the voters can do their thing in 2008 and fill the open seat?

I'd prefer the latter; it's the option that is most fair not only to the voters, but also to anyone who might be considering a run for office in '08. It presents a more level playing field in April 2008 than we'd have in June 2007.

I have talked to a number of people about it, and the consensus seems to be the "caretaker" option is unlikely. There's a shortage of qualified people who would be willing and able to take on the task.

What you'll likely see publicly, then, is a council appointment of someone who will be your next council member - not just for a year, but for at least the ensuing four, eight or maybe even 12 years.

The process, unfortunately, may be similar to the one College of the Canyons used in filling the board of trustees seat vacated by Ron Gillis a few months back: They announced the vacancy, accepted applications from 21 aspiring board members, interviewed them all in a span of less than five hours, then spent less than a half-hour deliberating before choosing Scott Wilk, the former campaign manager for half of the four board members voting.

Nothing against Scott. I like the guy. But that decision was SO made before the first application even came in. The interviews were for show.

Expect the same thing with the City Council.

There will be a process by which anyone can apply, but with a wink and a nudge, the council members will appoint someone they're already thinking of appointing. If you think they're not already talking about it among themselves, I've got some beachfront property in Palmdale...

As one observer noted in the newsroom this week, hopefully they're at least smart enough to spend more time deliberating than the COC board did.

Ironically, if it goes the way we can expect it to, I'll hate the process - but like the result. The decision will essentially be a (possibly illegal) back-room deal. (OK, I can't prove that ... but who are we kidding?) Still, odds are, we will get a better representative than what we'd get through a special election.

The person who gets appointed will have the advantage of running in '08 with the benefit of incumbency without having earned it - yet, even that will beat the alternative.

It all goes to show, even locally, politics is just like romance.

It gets messy sometimes.

Tim Whyte is The Signal's general manager. E-mail: [email protected].

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-ds:34232.
System
displaystory pages (?module=displaystory)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: latest capture. On this copy: words 1,007 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
displaystory:print_view
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies (1)

Host
the-signal.com
http://www.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=34232&format=html
Captured14 November 2006, 17:19:23 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-2564467fdbd42bc81d67bfd701ad9c628023d60ea6903b0f9fa37ffcfb5a9dae435SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: OLJCF27WQMASXXF6KZ34UH66WY47N7XM.
Holds alone
nothing measured beyond the chosen copy

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [[address]]
  • text:valley_names [5 distinct/7 mentions: Santa Clarita, College of the Canyons, COC, City Council, Cemex]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Smyth”, “Cameron Smyth”, “Scott Wilk”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0