The City Council did the right thing Tuesday night when it tabled a proposal to ban self-storage facilities along Santa Clarita’s main thoroughfares.
However, the proposal isn’t necessarily dead — and perhaps it should be.
After receiving numerous complaints from business owners who were, understandably, highly concerned about the proposal’s impact on their livelihood, the council opted instead to form a subcommittee to study the issue.
We hope the subcommittee — consisting of Councilwoman Laurene Weste and Councilman Bob Kellar — comes to the conclusion that the city would be better off applying good planning principles to individual projects rather than specifically targeting one particular type of business as being “undesirable.”
Under the proposal originally put forth by Kellar, new self-storage facilities would have been outlawed on four-, six- or eight-lane streets. As the rationale goes, those businesses are “eyesores.” As it also happens, they don’t generate much sales tax revenue for the city’s coffers.
While it’s true that some self-storage facilities are unsightly, it’s unfair to paint them all with the same broad brush — and it also flies in the face of American free enterprise principles to forbid someone from opening an otherwise legal business at a particular location simply because local government officials don’t like that type of business, or because it won’t generate sales tax revenue.
The ordinance would not have banned existing businesses, but would have required them to obtain special permission from the city before modifying or expanding operations.
As one might expect, some business owners were alarmed by the proposal and feared that it would mean their days are numbered. As one storage facility owner described it, the proposal was like putting “an atom bomb down a gopher hole.”
We’re glad to see that the City Council listened to the concerns of business owners. The council ultimately did the right thing Tuesday night, and as Kellar and Weste continue to evaluate the idea, we hope they bear in mind a couple of key points.
First, this is supposedly a pro-business city that respects the rights of property owners to use their land, within reason. Self-storage facilities are not drug dens or porn parlors, and if the right design considerations are taken into account, they need not be eyesores — so it shouldn’t matter to the city whether they’re on a two-lane road or a four-lane road.
Second, the city should be able to promote better-looking main thoroughfares through the application of sound planning principles, regardless of the type of business involved. Yes, not every project will be suitable for a given piece of property. And there are, certainly, locations in Santa Clarita that are entirely unsuitable for self-storage facilities — and some other types of businesses, too — but it’s difficult to believe that means those businesses need to be outlawed from all major thoroughfares. If the city makes smart decisions about proposed developments on an individual basis, the aesthetic concerns should take care of themselves.
We’re glad to see our city leaders are concerned about making commercial corridors as economically vibrant and visually pleasing as possible. That’s a worthy goal. But it need not be achieved by virtue of new rules that brand a particular type of business as nothing more than commercial riffraff.
