ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Power brokering and your hometown

The hits just keep coming.

This week, your City Council pulled the latest stunt that unfortunately illustrates how far we have come as a city. Or not, depending on one’s perspective.

It all started so simply, and it easily could have been handled in such a way as to not be objectionable at all.

What we ended up with, though, was the council deciding in secret to form a new advisory committee, then secretly selecting the people who will serve on the committee, then refusing to publicly disclose the list of names.

Secrets, secrets, secrets.

The existence of the committee itself is no big deal — it’s even advisable. The committee will advise the council on the selection of a new city manager. It’s a fine concept.

The new city manager will, by the way, be Ken Pulskamp, the longtime assistant city manager who is now serving as acting city manager. Nothing against Ken, but I’m betting this is a foregone conclusion and the nationwide search is just a drill...

So long as we’re all conducting ourselves as if this is an actual recruitment process, it makes good sense, especially when filling such an important position, to have an advisory group interview finalists and give input to the council. It can help ensure public “buy-in” to the hiring of a new chief administrator. It also exposes the council to diverse, informed opinions and helps ensure that a broad array of interests are taken into account.

Maybe.

It also could be a committee cleverly stacked with people of a like mind — you know, a group that may not have a great deal of prominence, is a bit under the public’s radar, but is well-connected to forces on the City Council who wish to guide the city manager selection process toward a predetermined goal.

We can’t evaluate it for ourselves yet, and neither can you, because the City Council decided to form this committee without telling you in advance, and chose the committee members without a public vote. Sure, they’re going to make a show of doing it publicly in their next meeting, but don’t kid yourself: This deal was done last week when Mayor Frank Ferry announced the council had “selected” people to serve on the committee.

I know the council has the legal right to conduct much of the hiring process privately. But secretly naming a committee in order to create the impression of community involvement — well, the irony is just delicious.

It may technically have been legal. But that doesn’t make it right.

— — —

I really think Councilman Bob Kellar wants to do the right things. Bob is a good guy with good intentions and he has done a great deal for this community. But if I disagree with him, I’ll say so — and I know he’s been none too happy about that lately.

One case in point is his advocacy of a strange pair of new laws regulating the placement of businesses. First, he wanted to ban the construction of any new car dealerships in town, unless they were in the Valencia auto mall.

And now, he wants to ban any new self-storage facilities along main thoroughfares: Any road of four lanes or more. Self-storage facilities, you see, are considered by many to be eyesores.

I’ve always liked Bob, but when he started this stuff a couple of months ago, I had to ask him when he became the planning equivalent of Seinfeld’s soup Nazi. I was only half-joking.

In Tuesday night’s council meeting, Kellar made a telling statement: He said self-storage facilities are not “a responsible use for our commercial property.”

“Our”? What constitutes “our” commercial property? Last time I checked, local governance does not equate to municipal property ownership. As a property rights advocate, I would suggest that if the city doesn’t want storage facilities on “our” commercial property, the city should buy the land.

Otherwise, stick to regulations that are reasonable, not punitive.

— — —

Not to keep picking on Bob, but we gave Kellar a great deal of space on this page last week to explain why he voted against Councilman Cameron Smyth’s campaign finance reform plan.

Kellar’s guest column spent many words explaining what Smyth’s proposal would not have done: It would not have solved all problems related to political action committees’ ability to raise massive amounts of money, unfettered by local regulations, and it would not have solved the problem at the state level, which filters down to local elections like ours.

This much is true.

But I stand by my previous statements: Kellar, Ferry and Councilwoman Marsha McLean should be ashamed for refusing to take the reasonable step proposed by Smyth, which would have sent the message that they care about leveling the playing field by preventing city-registered PACs from engaging in the sort of five-figure influence-buying that occurred in April’s election.

It’s worth noting that nowhere in Kellar’s column did he explain what he WOULD do to reform local campaign finance. In fact, since last month’s 3-2 rejection of Smyth’s proposal, we’ve heard nothing from Ferry, McLean or Kellar regarding how they would improve the system.

Interesting. Does anyone else see the status quo looming large in the 2004 election?

— — —

Speaking of influence peddling: It will be interesting to see if Waste Management Inc. convinces the council that a material recovery facility needs to be within city limits as part of the new trash contract.

Waste Management, one of the city’s current haulers, and Browning Ferris Industries, which doesn’t haul trash here but wants to, are each trying to get their way on the MRF. If it’s required to be in the city, it favors Waste Management, which does not have a landfill nearby. If it’s not, it favors haulers like BFI, which could use MRFs at their existing landfills without having to build one in the city.

I don’t have loyalty to any hauler. I just want the public to get the best combination of service and price. If it’s Waste Management, fine. If it’s BFI or some other haulers, fine. And if there’s no substantial public benefit to having a MRF in town — and right now it appears that there isn’t — it shouldn’t be a requirement of the contract.

It’ll be fascinating to see which City Council members go to bat for Waste Management on this one.

— — —

Maybe I’m the lone voice in the wilderness on this stuff, but I care about this place and it bothers me to see these sorts of shenanigans going on with our local government. I have a problem with closed-door dealings that should be public, a tilted playing field for campaign contributions and local lawmaking that is driven less by what’s really best for the entire city than it is by what’s best for a particular circle of friends.

If that makes me unpopular with the political “in” crowd around town, so be it. I just hope this pattern changes sometime soon.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:1013.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,181 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/5 mentions: Valencia, City Council]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0