Investors in a proposed landfill in Elsmere Canyon will only be owed money if the current landowner goes ahead with the project, an arbitration panel tentatively ruled last week.
An attorney for a group of jilted investors in the Elsmere Canyon landfill sued current owner Browning Ferris Industries in 1998, alleging the company and BKK Corp., the previous property owner purchased by BFI, bilked millions from the group. The investors wanted to install a 190-million-ton dump in Elsmere Canyon, south of state Route 14.
Leonard Sands, the attorney for plaintiffs Virginia Langford and roughly 20 other investors, said the three-member panel issued a preliminary ruling that would grant the backers financial compensation only if BFI continued with its plan to put a dump in the canyon. Otherwise, Sands said, the parties get nothing.
However, Sands said he believes BFI has already used the money for landfill purposes.
“We believe they used the money to assist in expanding Sunshine (Canyon Landfill),” he said.
BFI owns and operates Sunshine Canyon Landfill and is expected to bid on Santa Clarita’s residential and commercial trash contracts next year.
Sands also said money went into the purchase of a race track in Paris and an insurance policy to cover liabilities of BFI’s closing of a landfill in West Covina.
Sands said his clients still believe Elsmere is a perfect location for a landfill because of its remoteness. The canyon remains at the top of a county sanitation department siting list for landfill locations.
Greg Loughnane, BFI Los Angeles district manager, said the company agreed with the board’s decision.
“(The ruling) reflects the evidence presented and certainly upholds what the law justifies,” Loughnane said.
Loughnane said the company doesn’t have any plans for the property.
In February 2001, BFI said it would offer up Elsmere in exchange for a 20-year trash hauling contract with the city. The City Council balked and kept current haulers Waste Management Inc. and Republic Consolidated.
“At this point we have nothing planned,” Loughnane said. “It’s not the first thing on our priority list. It’s basically on the back burner.”
The case went to arbitration as called for in the contract between the investors and BKK. Sands said there is little likelihood his clients would get to appeal.
Sands said his clients weren’t giving up that easily.
“We’re not done by a long-shot with this,” he said.
The city of Santa Clarita spent millions of dollars in the early 1990s defeating the landfill. The project was ultimately scuttled in 1996 when President Clinton signed legislation by U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., and U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, that banned the transfer of national forest land for the purposes of establishing a landfill.
