Civil disobedience may tend to rub our town’s dominant conservative sensibilities the wrong way, but it’s difficult not to identify with John Quigley and his physically more grounded compatriots as they rally sympathy for a stately old oak tree that stands in the way of a road widening project.
We’ve managed to set aside, for the moment, since it serves our purpose, our disdain for outsiders who interfere with “our” politics, as this professional actor-turned-activist from Pacific Palisades propels our problematic oak into living rooms across the Southland day after day on our behalf.
In the process we’ve even cast wrongful aspersions against one of our own, an SCV-dwelling developer who no sooner yearns to fund the county road department’s lust for asphalt than I want to pay my income taxes — and against a county supervisor who is not a king but rather a seasoned and temperate public servant who holds but one of five cards and must ultimately abide the decisions of blind-eyed bureaucrats in the faraway and cheerless Los Angeles County Kenneth Hahn Hall of Administration.
For this is more than an oak tree. It is a symbol of our discontent, a symptom of our incapacity to find intelligent ways to harmonize our temporal needs with an environment that is simultaneously enjoyable and inconvenient, an incarnation of our rage against the bulldozer that constantly corrects the hillside that wasn’t whittled smoothly or flatly enough in the first place.
It is the latest manifestation of the reason we took matters into our own hands after so many years of county control — albeit too late to do much good, or much harm, within the municipal borders that the county conceded to us.
We need to be smarter, act smarter, try harder to strike a balance in our quest for living space, but how far are we willing to go? We want our children to afford their first home, yet our builders tell us roughly $50,000 of every new-home price pays not for the bricks and mortar but for the government-mandated costs of constructing roads, schools and water lines. We want to get from Canyon Country to the Valencia Town Center in under an hour, but do we really want to “make the developers pay” if that translates into more housing tract approvals — and fewer oak trees and hilltops? And if not, then how much are we willing to tax ourselves to put that road through on our own?
Do we build up instead of out? What’s more important, our skyline view or the decimation of unspoiled territory on our outskirts? And what happens when 100,000 more people live to the west of Interstate 5 — 70,000 just in Newhall Ranch — and we all want to drive over the hill at once? Do we widen the freeway to 16 or 20 lanes, if that’s even sufficient, or do we supplant the automobile — and our independence — with costly bullet trains?
Compromises. We make them every day, sometimes wittingly, sometimes not. We’ve drawn our line in the Pico Canyon sand where we expect our government officials, elected and otherwise, to do the impossible in a crevice too narrow to accommodate both a majestic oak tree and an ample supply of asphalt to get us from here to there without going postal during some future rush hour.
For many of the activists who’ve gathered in and under and around the tree these past two fortnights, relief would come in the form of a temporary reprieve — their rationale being that much can change in the next five or 10 or 15 years before there’s enough new growth to actually necessitate a four-lane road in Pico Canyon. Wait to see if there’s enough water, or money, or whatever, before taking the irreversible action of removing the tree, they say.
They point by way of example to Valley Street in Newhall where the county, in the years prior to city formation, determined that the road should connect with Calgrove Boulevard as a secondary highway. The county took out several oak trees to make way for the road-widening project — but then never widened the road. Eventually the City Council decided the road should be shut — but it couldn’t put back the trees.
Others believe a short-term solution isn’t a solution at all; it’s just delaying the inevitable, pushing back the decision to a future time when there will be more activists, and more neighboring homeowners, who will take umbrage.
Can a four-lane road be designed to go around the tree? It’s not an easy question to answer. We don’t have benefit of a full-blown Environmental Impact Report, so there’s little information on alternatives to running the road into the tree.
Try to suggest a divided roadway with the tree in the middle, and you’ll raise the eyebrows of county lawyers who will say it’s far more dangerous to careening motorists and thus more likely to elicit lawsuits. Try to cram four lanes on the south side of the tree and you might end up in a new homeowner’s back yard. Move it, as if it belonged somewhere else, and there’s a possibility it might die.
It’s more than an oak tree, much more.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s City Editor. His commentary appears Wednesdays.
