In the mid-1990s, when the City Council first weighed the prospects of providing winter shelter for the homeless, Signal cartoonist Randy Wicks drew an editorial cartoon depicting the situation.
The Interfaith Council wanted the city to help open a homeless shelter, and the first frame of the Wicks cartoon depicted the plan for the shower and laundry planned by the Interfaith Council, showing a man happily taking a shower in an indoor facility where his clothes were being washed.
The City Council, at the time, balked at the idea. So Wicks’ second frame showed an entirely different scenario depicting the council’s plan: It was a homeless man, shivering outside in the rain, and a bar of soap was flying toward him, having been tossed by someone outside the frame.
This, Wicks said, was the shower and laundry offered to the homeless by the City Council.
Things have changed since then, as the City Council for the past several years has provided a site for a homeless shelter. The winter-only shelter is operated by the non-profit Santa Clarita Community Development Corp., and Wicks, who died in 1996, would be pleased to see the assistance given to those who would otherwise spend winter nights exposed to the elements.
The shelter started out on a piece of city property near the Santa Clarita Sports Complex, but that site is now being developed into an aquatics center to serve the entire community.
Finding a new location has proved challenging. Even those who support the shelter seem to do so under one condition: That it is nowhere near their own home or business.
Some of the stated reasons for residents’ objections have not been supported by the facts. The area surrounding the homeless shelter has not proven to become a haven for drugs and crime, and there has not been a general degradation of the community. Further, the homeless have not flocked to Santa Clarita because there is a shelter here.
The “homelessness problem” in Santa Clarita is not widespread, but the fact is there are local people who need the help. The shelter has proven worthwhile, serving dozens at a time — often including families with children.
The Community Development Corp. examined more than two dozen potential locations this year, and it was decided the shelter would be set up in the parking lot of the Via Princessa Metrolink station. The nighttime-only shelter is scheduled to open Dec. 1 and continue until March.
The site at first glance seems suitable — it’s in something of an industrial area, not immediately adjacent to homes. But just up the road, its nearest neighbors are objecting vehemently to the shelter being so close. In some ways, you can’t fault them.
There’s the conundrum.
We want to be a city of compassion, where we help our neighbors who have fallen on hard times. Many of us ask ourselves the frightening question, “How many paychecks away from homelessness am I?”
But we also want to protect the things that prompt us to call this community home: Nice neighborhoods, good schools, good property values, a low crime rate. A homeless shelter doesn’t necessarily diminish all of that — but it does diminish the perception of a neighborhood. Who, in all honesty, wants to give directions to one’s home or business that include the phrase, “Turn left after the homeless shelter”?
Our city leaders are trying to do the right thing. They’re trying to provide the shelter in a location where it will cause minimal disruption to Santa Claritans’ lives. It’s a noble effort.
But it will continue to be embroiled in debate until a location can be found where the shelter can operate each year. Ideally, there would be an offer from a land owner who has the perfect piece of property, not in close proximity to residential and retail areas.
Until such a site is found, we are in all likelihood doomed to an ongoing annual debate over where the shelter should be. Many will agree that providing one is the right thing to do — but when you ask where it should be, the answer invariably will be, “Somewhere on the other side of town.”
The debate will stir feelings of geographic rivalry, too. If the shelter is on the east side, as planned this year, nearby residents will contend the city is playing favorites, keeping the shelter away from Valencia and the west side. We don’t believe that’s actually what’s happening. If anything, the city spends a disproportionate share of its money for community improvements on projects on the east side of town — so it’s not fair to say City Hall views the east side as a dumping ground. But that perception is inexorably fed by the current placement of the shelter.
There is no easy solution. Our City Council has moved well past its mid-1990s offer to toss a bar of soap out into the rain — but what this shelter really needs is a private party to emerge as the hero.
