ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

John Q.’s Public, Old Glory’s Fiasco

Everyone botched it.

That was the conclusion I drew Friday night, standing in Pico Canyon amid protesters and curiosity-seekers as rescue workers were called in to perform a rather unusual extraction: The forcible removal of a man who had been living in an oak tree for 71 days.

It was an act that should have been unnecessary. And all of the responsible parties — the county, developer John Laing Homes and the environmental community — share in the blame.

Collectively, they failed to solve the problem. Tree sitter John Quigley and the oak, “Old Glory,” were standing in the way of progress. When all was said and done in the press and the courts, the order came down that Quigley was to be evicted from the tree.

And so he was.

I’ve never been what you would call an anti-growth zealot. Sometimes, I’ve been called the opposite. I’ve always found it ironic that many of those who protest rampant growth and the chopping down of a tree are the same people who live in tract houses plopped right smack on the former home of some former tree. If growth is a problem, every last one of us is a part of it.

Regardless, I believe in a property owner’s rights, and I believe reasonable, well-planned growth can be a healthy exercise of those rights. But with all rights come responsibilities.

In the case of John Laing Homes, the builder could have designed its Pico Canyon development more thoughtfully in the first place. The homes it built on the south side of Pico, before this fateful road-widening project began, essentially painted the developer into a corner, making it impossible to honor the spirit of an agreement it struck with local environmentalists several years ago regarding the fate of Oak No. 419.

Then there was the way the developer handled the ouster of Quigley’s “ground crew” this week, setting the stage for Friday night’s fireworks.

If you’re in the right, if you have not only the legal imperative but also the moral one, too, why act under the cover of darkness?

The 2 a.m. Thursday raid that shooed the activists away would have drawn more media coverage and scrutiny in daylight — something people generally don’t go out of their way to avoid if they are proud of their actions.

It conjured images, rightly or wrongly, of jackbooted thugs being called in to forcibly squelch a peaceful protest. If nothing else, John Laing Homes could have used better PR advice.

Then there’s the county government.

For some reason, they’re hell-bent to get Pico widened from two lanes to four, despite the fact that there’s some question over whether it’s needed. A few years ago, officials of The Newhall Land and Farming Co. said they didn’t plan to use Pico as a primary route to the developer’s massive 21,000-home Newhall Ranch project. But county officials are steadfast in their assertion that Pico must be widened not only for Newhall Ranch, but also for later phases of Stevenson Ranch.

There’s probably more going on there than meets the eye. Regardless, even if you presume the road needs widening, the county could have done a better job of enforcing good planning, which could have allowed enough room between the homes and the tree.

And, there’s the environmental community, which has been viewed by many, but not all, as the sympathetic figure in this drama.

Several years ago, when the agreement was struck regarding Oak No. 419, the environmentalists who agreed to it either failed to notice — or disregarded — the loophole in the deal. If you read it carefully, it basically says the developer will take actions to preserve and protect the oak, despite the fact that the tree would lie directly in the path of the new westbound lanes.

It seems they got caught napping.

All of this prompted the two-month tree-sitting ordeal, in which Quigley, an out-of-towner who specializes in such things, was called in as a human shield to protect the tree. It culminated in the Friday night Pico carnival. Among the crowd were residents, activists, children, dogs, teenagers and couples changing up the “date night” routine.

Some carried signs, and some started chants, giving the evening a surreal “Jerry Springer Show” feeling:

“Let Quigley go! Let Quigley go!”

And, later, as the mood degenerated: “Throw your poop! Throw your poop!”

Yup. It wasn’t always what you would call a high-brow affair.

The neighbors got into the act, too. I’m sure most of the people in the immediate area are nice folks who have quietly tolerated the traffic, the media attention and so forth. It has surely been a pain in the rear for them.

But there was one home where a backyard gathering of people watched and heckled the gathered protesters below. At one point, a man yelled from up there, “Pipe down! My kid’s sleeping!” Someone from the crowd shouted some sort of reply, to which the resident shouted, “Go back to Pacoima where you live, F---head!”

Thus, it was proven that living in a half-million-dollar house does not necessarily equate to having class.

Fortunately, the evening ended without much in the way of violence — although for a while I stood next to a couple of jerks who came very close to blows, each of them on the opposite side of the tree debate. It would have been a brawl except the place was crawling with sheriff’s deputies.

To their credit, the deputies and other county personnel who extracted Quigley conducted themselves as the professionals they are. To his credit, too, Quigley went peacefully — and made sure everyone knew he was well-treated by the Sheriff’s Department.

Thus, the circus came to an end, at least temporarily. Quigley briefly addressed the crowd in an impromptu “victory” speech, then spotted a friend, hugged him and said, “We’re going to play some hoop now!”

As of this writing, it’s not clear when they’ll start yanking Old Glory from the space it has occupied for, if not 400 years, then at least some large fraction thereof. I wonder if the tree will survive the move. I can’t help thinking it’s as good as firewood by now. I also can’t help wondering how this might have played out if a lot of people — developers, activists, bureaucrats, politicians — had exercised more forethought.

A couple of weeks ago, this newspaper editorialized that all parties involved needed some solution, a brilliant face-saving way to emerge from the situation with an agreeable resolution to their dispute. We editorialized that all of them needed, more than anything else, a graceful exit.

This wasn’t it.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:1650.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,120 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [5 distinct/9 mentions: Newhall, Stevenson Ranch, Pico Canyon, Newhall Land, Newhall Ranch]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0