Now what?
After a tumultuous two-month standoff and debate over the fate of Oak Tree No. 419 in Pico Canyon, what lessons can be drawn and what actions should be taken?
Obviously, the legal wrangling is expected to continue as environmentalists, including the ousted tree-sitter, John Quigley, exhaust their options in an attempt to preserve the tree that became known as Old Glory.
Those efforts, in all likelihood, will be in vain. Even if it’s relocated, the tree’s prospects for survival are questionable.
But if Old Glory can leave behind a legacy, we hope it’s one of improved vision and anticipation on the part of those who are responsible for planning our valley’s future growth.
Pico Canyon Road is not finished. It may end up connecting to the largest development ever considered by Los Angeles County, the Newhall Ranch project proposed by The Newhall Land and Farming Co. At 21,000 homes, Newhall Ranch will pack a wallop in terms of traffic and other impacts. Even if Pico isn’t considered a primary means of access, you can bet there will be some demand for it.
Something we called for early in the “Old Glory” debate — and something that should still be considered, regardless of what happens with that particular tree — is a comprehensive environmental study of the Pico Canyon corridor and the effects that widening and extending the road will have, along with ways to minimize the impacts.
We have long advocated well-planned growth, and we continue to do so. The principles of well-planned growth should not have necessarily precluded Pico Canyon Road from being widened, nor should they necessarily preclude it from becoming an access route to newly developing communities on the west end of our valley.
However, debacles like the one we witnessed over Old Glory can and should be avoided. It doesn’t take an engineering degree to see that the development near Old Glory could have been tweaked in the planning stages so as to allow enough clearance for the road and the tree. The tree, with a bit of thought, could have been incorporated as a pleasing aspect of one’s passage through the new neighborhood.
The “jam ’em in” approach to planning can create such problems: Developers try to carve as many buildable lots as possible out of a piece of property. That’s only natural. It’s a business.
But the county as gatekeeper should be identifying potential problem areas and taking measures to ensure that appropriate steps are taken to prevent a repeat of the past couple of months.
It would be naive to believe no oak tree should ever be sacrificed in the name of progress. But when it’s possible to give some extra consideration to a senior member of the oak community, all reasonable steps should be taken. It appears that wasn’t the case with Old Glory, and the result has been a public relations nightmare for the county and the developer.
Surely, none of them want to go through that again.
