No matter what you think about school uniforms, one thing is undeniably true about them:
They’re basically pointless if the students don’t wear them.
That is the conclusion that Sierra Vista Junior High School and Castaic Middle School have both drawn, prompting them to end a school uniform experiment that began in 1996 at Sierra Vista and in 1999 at Castaic.
It was the correct decision.
Even if you are a proponent of school uniforms, it’s undeniable that the desired effects of a uniform policy are difficult to obtain. Under state law, schools must allow parents to enable their students to “opt out” of the uniform policy — so the notion of a “mandatory” uniform policy is a myth at best.
At Castaic and Sierra Vista, the number of students wanting to opt out has been on the rise each year, continually decreasing the relevance of the uniform policy.
The arguments in favor of school uniforms are certainly appealing to parents who care about their kids’ environment. Uniform proponents say school uniforms diminish dress code problems, promote unity and create an overall safer campus environment unblemished by gang attire, baggy jeans and limit-testing outfits that bare as much skin as can be bared without getting arrested.
As compelling as those arguments sound, though, there are also compelling arguments against them: Do we really all have to wear the same clothes to be “safe”? So much for the American notion of individuality. And, it’s somewhat unsettling to indoctrinate children to the notion that it’s OK for the government — a public school — to require specific clothing items to be worn by all.
If nothing else, though, there is compelling local evidence that a uniform policy is unnecessary for a school to achieve excellence. This year, Arroyo Seco Junior High School was recognized as a National Blue Ribbon School — and the students at Arroyo Seco do not wear uniforms.
Obviously, schools must maintain and enforce a dress code in order to maintain the proper sense of decorum. Beyond that, regardless of whether you personally favor or oppose uniforms, they clearly serve little purpose if they aren’t worn by the vast majority of the students.
Considering that fact, Castaic and Sierra Vista have simply made the practical choice.
