There’s pretty much no way for me to say this without sounding like either a prude or a dirty old man.
On past occasions, I have been accused of being both. But what I am striving for here is not so much prudishness, nor to be seen as a drooling codger in a trenchcoat.
Rather, I wish to be The Voice of Reason.
I plan to make a mighty effort. But I feel sort of like I do when I’m at the top of a ski run that is beyond my ability level: I just know I’m going to crash somewhere on this mountain.
I’m jumping anyway. Here goes:
I am neither offended by, yet nor do I endorse, the attire of the Saugus High School dance team. Further, if there is any “problem” with the dance team’s threads, it has a lot less to do with the virtue of those teen-age girls than it does with the teen-age boys who watch them perform.
The question came up last month when we got a letter to the editor from a former Saugus High dance team member who’s “all growed up” now. As an adult, she is appalled by the costumes worn by the current members of her former dance team.
She likened the dancers’ costumes to the attire one might find — well, briefly anyway — on a stripper. The letter-writer further hinted that some of the girls’ risque dance moves might also be more suitable for a lap dance than a high school dance show.
The letter prompted a litany of responses from parents and others defending the dance team, its moves, its adviser and its choice of attire.
I didn’t plan to weigh in on it — until I saw Friday’s edition of The Zone, our weekly teen section. This week’s “Zone” featured a nice story with photos of the Saugus High dance team.
Now, I’m sure all of the girls of the Saugus High School dance team are delightful, virtuous young ladies, and I’m sure their parents and adviser are involved, caring adults who want the best for the girls. I’m also told that, collectively, the dancers do very well in school, so this is no collection of gum-snapping, street-walking hussies.
And let the record reflect that I do not make a habit of ogling scantily clad high school girls.
Well. Not much.
I am, however, here to tell you that — regardless of the moral character of these girls, regardless of their grades, regardless of whether they are as pure as the driven Wasatch Mountain snow, and regardless of whether Mom and Dad think the outfits are merely the sorts of things worn by “serious” dancers — their dance attire, coupled with their modern dance moves, will only bring one thing to mind for any red-blooded American teen-aged boy who watches them perform.
It rhymes with “flex.”
That’s the one thing that is no different now than it was when I went to Saugus High School, back in the dark ages of the early-’80s. I was there, by cracky, when the dance team was created — well, not the girls themselves, but the team — and I remember being chagrined that some of the hottest of the hotties of the class of ’84 had bypassed the cheerleading squad so they could join the new dance team.
It just didn’t seem right. It threw my whole world view off-kilter. Those girls were supposed to be cheerleaders, weren’t they? Fortunately, then, as now, Saugus High had enough pretty girls, God bless ’em, to fully staff both the cheerleading squad AND the dance team.
The dance team’s outfits were sexy enough back then: Pretty much skin-tight pantsuits, in the school colors of course. Back then, unlike today, the girls wore the same costume for just about all of their performances. Not much flesh exposed, but the costumes hugged the curves well enough that the imaginations of us teen-aged boys could run wild with thoughts of filling in the blanks.
And don’t kid yourself: We guys were very specific in discussing the particular, er, attributes of one girl or another. No body part was exempt from the analysis. Yes. Teen-aged boys are pigs. I know. I was one of them.
Now, many, many years later, I look at the pictures of the current dance team and those same thoughts, thank goodness, don’t run through my mind. The girls just look, well, young to me. Too young, really, which is a sign of my rapidly advancing age.
But it’s easy enough to figure out what I would be thinking about them if I were, say, 17, with a brand new driver’s license in my wallet, right behind the condom forming the telltale permanent ring in the leather.
The Big Question: Do the costumes exceed what’s acceptable for a high school production? Are they too sexy?
Regrettably, I think the answer is “yes.”
It’s not that the dance team has incorporated frontal nudity into the routines, nor do the girls appear to be especially slutty. There are no twirling tassels, and no G-strings with dollar bills dangling precariously. The girls’ faces bear expressions that are more youthful jubilance than “come-hither, sailor.”
But man. Are you folks sure those costumes don’t go too far?
The costumes aren’t revealing, per se. All the most important body parts are covered. A typical harmless swimsuit shows more flesh, but that’s not the entire point: The clothes are suggestive. And “revealing” and “suggestive” are two different things.
In some ways, the outfits aren’t any more revealing than other things the girls wear these days. (God, how I dread the day my daughter gets to high school...)
For example, the short red skirts featured in the performance we photographed for The Zone aren’t any shorter than cheerleaders’ skirts. The style of the skirt, however — a tight red one with a little slit up the side — makes it much more suggestive.
And the bare midriffs — well, you can’t swing a dead cat at the mall without hitting a teen-ager’s exposed belly button these days. In the Saugus dance production, there they are, teen-aged girls dancing like Britney with their belly buttons showing.
As a guy, I have a certain level of appreciation for that bare-midriff trend, thanks to the recent crop of pop tarts in the music industry. As a dad, though, it literally sends a chill up my spine. It’s one of the rules of fatherhood, I guess: You don’t mind girls wearing sexy attire so long as your daughter isn’t the one wearing it — and DANCING, for cryin’ out loud, with an audience that may include teen-aged boys who, say it with me, ONLY THINK ABOUT SEX.
It doesn’t stop with the navels. Just above those belly buttons, there’s a red thing — what? A halter top? — and over that, a see-through black mesh top that allows nubile young cleavage to peek through from underneath.
I don’t remember the dance team girls showing cleavage like that when I was in high school. And trust me. I’d remember.
It wasn’t just the red mini-skirt-black-mesh-halter top outfit, either. The costumes for another routine we photographed featured black cocktail-looking skirts showing what must have been literally miles of thigh.
You get the idea.
Truly, no “private” body parts were shown. And yes, I know the girls wear dancers’ briefs that ensure the show will never get an NC-17 rating.
But if you can, for a moment, put yourself in the shoes of a teen-age boy, hormones just raging through your body looking for a way to burst out. Then look at the picture of the dancing girls.
You’re getting IDEAS, aren’t you?
Obviously, in this as in many other things, community standards of acceptability have changed. I imagine if this were the 1950s and these young pretties had danced in those clothes — and used today’s hip-grinding moves — they’d have been hauled down to the local constable’s office for a serious talking-to.
“For cryin’ out loud, put some clothes on,” the gendarmes would have told them.
Like I said at the top: I am not personally offended by it, especially because those girls are not my daughters. But if they were...
Call me what you want. Dirty old man, prude, or, I hope, The Voice of Reason.
Regardless, I still remember vividly what goes through teen-aged boys’ minds. And if my precious young daughter comes to me in 15 years wearing little more than fishnets and pasties and says, “Daddy, I want to be on the high school dance team and this is what I’d get to wear...”
Well, I imagine they’ll have to peel me off the ceiling.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
