Break out the pasties and the G-strings — everything goes in the Hart school district!
The high school district’s board of trustees voted 3-2 on Wednesday night to cave in to the demands of parents who seem to believe no boundaries are needed for high school performing groups.
Any dance move.
Any clothing choice.
It’s all fair game. Cleavage? Show all you want! Bare midriffs? Hey, it’s not about sex! It’s a competitive necessity!
The school board vetoed a proposed set of guidelines that would have established some minimum level of modesty in high school performances. The guidelines would have given high school principals the final say-so, and while there was more to it than this, the upshot was, “No navels, no cleavage.”
It seemed reasonable enough. I don’t expect the girls to dance in burkas, but it doesn’t seem out of line to employ some minimal standard of appropriateness.
However, a group of parents urged the school board to balk, and so they did, ignoring the staff recommendation to at least have some standards.
Some of those same parents blasted this newspaper for daring to publish certain photos of a recent Valencia High School dance performance.
The photos — one of which is reprinted here — accompanied a news story that posed the question, “Are these costumes appropriate?”
I’ll say this: The girls looked good.
They also looked 25.
Both sides of the story were told. The reporting was balanced. The story did what it was supposed to do: Explore a matter of public interest that was about to go before the school board.
The photos, both published and unpublished — more on that later — caused quite a stir among dance team parents.
I’d like to thank the parents who complained about the photos for proving my point. If there’s nothing wrong with the dance performances, the moves and the costumes, what can possibly be wrong with publishing photos of them?
Rather than griping about the publication of the photos, you would think those same parents would be visiting The Signal to buy extra copies of the paper.
Not so. Those parents are basically saying, “How dare you print that picture of those costumes that I’m saying are perfectly acceptable.”
Huh?
It defies logic.
Oh, the parents argue that the photos can be taken out of context — they each only represent a brief moment in a lengthy performance.
That doesn’t fly, either.
The photos were not altered in any way. They are accurate representations of what happened on stage, and I would submit that they actually don’t do justice to the “pushing-the-limits” nature of the performance, because still photographs don’t show movement, which would in all likelihood make the total picture all the more provocative, that much closer to the limits. (Oops! I forgot! In the Hart district, there ARE NO LIMITS! Silly me...)
There are those who object that the photographer obtained his images by zooming in with a telephoto lens. Well, he didn’t use any unusual photographic equipment, and his lens didn’t see anything that someone sitting in the front row didn’t see.
So it puzzles me to hear that some parents have basically branded our photographer as something just short of a pornographer — and all the while, defending the outfits and the moves. Weird.
Our photographer was sent to cover an assignment at a public high school. He did his job, and you know what? When he came back to the newsroom, he expressed extreme discomfort with the dance troupe’s choice of costumes and performance material.
And this is a young guy, not an old fuddy duddy like me. This is a young man who came back and told us there were moments in the show when he felt so uncomfortable that he lowered his camera and stopped shooting.
We published a few of the more conservative photos in our teen section, The Zone, as part of our routine coverage of the show. Regardless of whether we all see eye to eye on the costumes, those kids worked hard to put on a quality performance, and covering it is an important part of our job.
Then, when it came time to cover the school district’s proposed guidelines, we decided to show the photos to several school district officials in order to ask them the question, “Do you think this is appropriate?”
Three photos that had yet to be published were faxed to district officials and to the Valencia High principal’s office.
Like most newspapers, we do not normally release material before it is published. But we figured an exception was in order, because it would be difficult for officials to respond to something they could not see. So, we decided to extend a professional courtesy and provide them with copies of the photos.
It is a professional courtesy that will not be repeated on my watch.
The photos were shared with parents of the dance team members, stoking their feelings of contempt for the newspaper.
As it turned out, I made an editorial decision not to publish one of the photos. It was an image of a dancer who was sitting on a chair in a provocative position. She was clad in skintight black shorts and fishnets, and without going into too much detail, let’s just say I didn’t feel comfortable publishing it. The story could be told effectively without it, and publishing it would have seemed gratuitous. Our photographer had been shooting a fluid dance, and as this dancer moved, the resulting image showed her in a position that, in my opinion, would be inappropriate to show in a community newspaper, particularly considering her age.
So we didn’t print it.
The dance team parents saw it anyway, because someone abused the professional courtesy we extended when we provided administrators copies of the photos in advance of the story.
The parents hung their hats on that photo to support their assertion that our photographer had done something wrong.
Like they always say, when a problem arrives, blame the media.
Our photographer did nothing wrong. We covered a public performance at a public high school involving public high school students. The photos accurately depicted what happened on stage.
I don’t fault anyone for disagreeing with me about the costumes. Being able to express our differences is what makes this country great. But I do take issue with those who have said this newspaper has acted inappropriately. We have done our job: To report the news and raise questions about matters of local interest.
Further, I do have a problem with a school official who distributed unpublished material that had been provided only as a courtesy to facilitate that person’s ability to respond to an issue. (For the record, I have spoken with Superintendent Robert Lee and I am confident that he was not the individual who distributed the photos.)
Suffice it to say, I will not be trusting certain sources with copies of unpublished images if such a situation ever happens again. I hope it doesn’t. I’d much rather our debate were focused elsewhere.
To be honest, I feel like I should get either the credit or the blame for all this, depending on how you look at it. Last year, I wrote a column about the attire of the dance team at my alma mater, Saugus High School, and soon after that the school board was examining the issue.
That examination has resulted in... well, nothing. The school board says no standards are needed. Those of us who say otherwise are just a bunch of crazy prudes.
Tim Whyte, puritan.
Who would have thought?
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
