Maybe we’re prudes.
But when we saw the photos of a recent Valencia High School dance production, we couldn’t help thinking:
Those costumes. Those moves. Aren’t they a bit risqué?
As far as we could tell, there was no such reaction from the friends and family members — including parents — who saw the show.
Further, it was apparent that performers and spectators alike were rightly proud of the dancers’ outstanding training and ability to execute difficult routines. Regardless of whether we may disagree on the appropriateness of the costumes, we can all certainly agree that our valley’s high school performers are collectively exhibiting an impressive degree of talent and dedication.
But truth be told, there were some images from the high school dance production that we simply didn’t feel were appropriate for publication in a family newspaper. Further, our own photographer on that assignment — who is a young man — expressed some discomfort about the costumes and moves, to the point where there were some photos he didn’t feel comfortable shooting.
We took an informal poll of our own staff, too, just to be sure we weren’t being too old-fashioned. The opinions did vary somewhat, but even some of our 20-something newsroom staffers thought the high school show went too far.
Sure, the most strategic body parts were covered. Further, we are fully aware that, under today’s accepted fashion standards, teenagers routinely flaunt substantially more flesh even on a regular school day than we would have seen a couple of decades ago.
But would you publish photos in which it appears high school girls are simulating a lap dance while dressed in a manner that, if not excessively revealing, is undoubtedly provocative?
And when a high school girl is wearing fishnets and the shortest of shorts, positioned seductively on a chair with her legs apart — well, it goes beyond the level of appropriateness to publish it.
This of course raises the question: When we are simply covering an event at a public high school, should the dance moves and costumes be so provocative as to render the resulting images inappropriate for a community newspaper?
We think not.
We understand the competitive nature of modern high school dance teams. We certainly understand that, in competitions, dancers must have certain types of attire and execute certain types of moves in order to compete successfully. The costumes certainly need to show “body lines,” as one parent put it.
We understand, too, that we are no longer in the 1950s. No one expects a high school dance troupe in the year 2003 to take the stage in knee-highs, poodle skirts and turtlenecks.
However, lines ought to be drawn somewhere. It is, admittedly, somewhat subjective. But there is an inherent quality in some attire that is more suggestive than in other items of apparel, even if the amount of actual skin shown is the same.
We have to remember that these are public high school productions, involving young people who may be quite sophisticated in appearance and thought, yet are in fact still children.
There must be boundaries.
That’s why the board of trustees for the William S. Hart Union High School District did the wrong thing Wednesday night when it refused to approve a new set of guidelines for performance attire.
We commend board members Dennis King and Patricia Hanrion for casting the dissenting votes in the 3-2 decision, having the guts to stand up to those who attended the board meeting, voting on principles rather than political winds in the board room.
The arguments against the guidelines don’t hold water. For example, opponents contend it would be discriminatory because no such rules are applied in other sports. That argument presumes that dance is pure sport, rather than what it really is: An athletic art form that has been imported into a competitive sports-type environment.
There are obvious differences between gyrating dance moves — judged for visual impact — and, say, the movement of a Speedo-clad swimmer in a pool, seeking solely to go from Point A to Point B faster than the competition.
Other arguments focus on the lack of enforcement of a dress code at local high schools: They say the costumes don’t show anything that can’t be seen during an everyday lunch hour on campus.
True. The difference, though, is significant, even if one disregards the obvious “two wrongs don’t make a right” factor: There’s a major distinction between a student’s own personal wardrobe and the attire that is chosen as part of a school-sanctioned activity. One is the choice of students and parents, and the other is the choice of public educators.
The guidelines would have left a great degree of latitude to the high school principals. At minimum, it would have amounted to a policy statement on the district’s behalf essentially saying, “anything goes” is not a given.
It is now.
