As the city’s trash contracts come up for what may be the final stages of approval, there are many factors that will come into play.
We hope the two most important ones are service and price.
That, in no way, is meant to dismiss the input of those who may believe other factors should be considered. As with any local government decision, we advocate that the City Council listen carefully to all of the input it receives, give proper consideration to the various points of view presented, and make a decision that is in the best interests of the taxpayers.
That doesn’t mean the council should take a straw poll of those present and let the majority of those in council chambers prevail. Sometimes, the right decision requires the council to go against the grain of the crowd gathered in council chambers.
But under no circumstances would we advocate that anyone’s input be dismissed.
This clarification appears necessary because of feedback we’ve heard from some community leaders who seem to believe this newspaper thinks their input does not count.
That couldn’t be further from the truth.
Quite simply, as it regards the trash franchises, we have advocated that the City Council should get the best combination of service and price — period.
That means, for example, that a particular hauler’s record of charitable giving in the community should not be the determining factor. First and foremost, the trash franchises do not exist in order to redistribute wealth from the community to the many worthy local charitable organizations. Secondly, at least one reason that a hauler like Waste Management Inc. has such a stellar record of charitable giving in this town is the horrible contract negotiated by the city more than a decade ago.
Quite simply, Waste Management has been an outstanding corporate citizen, and we applaud it for doing so — but the undeniable fact remains that it has done so because it can afford to. Further, it would be no surprise to see that high level of charitable giving curtailed under the new contract, due to the simple fact that the hauler’s profit margin will be lower.
As a result of its history of generosity, Waste Management has a great number of friends among the community’s leadership — the people who are grateful that the hauler has supported one cause or another.
We’re grateful, too. However, we remain steadfast in our advocacy that the council choose the best combination of service and price.
Does that mean Waste Management may deserve all or part of the contract at this juncture?
Perhaps. We expect to find out this week. But in any case, charitable giving should not be the determining factor.
Conversely, that does not mean that any input from the “rubber chicken circuit” should be disregarded. Rather, the input from our community’s leaders and charity advocates should be given the same careful consideration as the input of any citizen of this city.
The council must weigh all of that input. And, when it’s all said and done, the council must choose the deal that is best for all of the city’s taxpayers, the deal that is — say it with us — the best combination of service and price.
