After more than two years of haggling and turmoil, the light is finally at the end of the tunnel in the debate over who will haul your trash in Santa Clarita.
The city is expected this week to release the latest details on the city staff’s negotiations with two haulers: Waste Management Inc. and Burrtec. The City Council might render a decision Thursday.
As we head into all of that, I just have a few questions, observations and issues that I believe ought to be brought up and discussed, openly:
— What the heck, exactly, did the City Council ask the staff to do a little over a month ago? A friend of mine had the decision-making part of the council meeting transcribed — I plan to publish some or all of it on the opinion page this week — and our council members sound like they’ve taken up gobbledygook as a second language. I was confused by a lot of their discussion at the time, but I thought it was just me. In reading the transcript, I feel much better.
It’s them.
— Is the goal to get the best deal, or to make sure each hauler gets a piece of the pie? At one point during the council’s baffling exchange with city staff, it seemed as if the reason everyone was doing so much tap-dancing around the issue was that they wanted to make all of the haulers happy. I sincerely hope that’s not at all a factor. I hope that what we’re seeing is a true search for the best deal — rather than a politically driven effort to keep all of the haulers happy. (Gee, I wonder if anyone else has thought of the potential benefits when it comes to campaign contributions if we have more than one happy local trash hauler who wants to stay...)
— Are we at the point where we have the best possible deal? The council’s directive was for the staff to negotiate to split the contract, with WMI getting residential and Burrtec getting commercial, and Burrtec building the oft-debated materials recovery facility — well, at least, most of us who’ve been following the issue think that’s what the council’s direction was. Based on the dialogue, that’s really just an educated guess.
Anyway, this week you can probably expect to see a proposed deal in which WMI gets the residential, and drops your trash rates immediately rather than two years from now when the new deal would actually take effect. The new seven-year contract is worth $60-million-plus, which represents a dramatic savings — perhaps tens of millions of dollars, depending on how you crunch the numbers — over what Santa Claritans would have paid if we just stuck with the existing haulers without going to an open bid process.
Remember, this bid process only occurred because of pressure applied by this newspaper two years ago when discrepancies were discovered in local waste diversion numbers and in the formula that was used to determine our existing trash rates, which are among the Southland’s highest. Yes folks, we’ve been getting ripped off for a decade, due in large part to the city’s failure in the early-1990s to recognize the wool being pulled over its eyes. Thankfully, we’re over that now.
— What are the ramifications of splitting the deal vs. giving both residential and commercial to one hauler? I’d bet WMI’s corporate leaders will be all too happy to just get the residential deal without having to provide commercial service and, more notably, spend $5 to $6 million building a MRF. That could be short-sighted on their part, because it lets Burrtec in town — a potential up side for local residents seven years down the road, when it comes time to go to bid on the NEXT contract. If WMI had the whole thing, including the MRF, it would be a repeat of what we have now: An unlevel playing field in favor of the incumbent hauler. But it would also cost them more up-front money to do it. If Burrtec is in town, serving commercial and running a MRF (and if Burrtec hasn’t been bought out by one of the bigger haulers, like WMI), when that next contract comes up it’s conceivable that, for the first time, WMI won’t hold every card in the deck.
— Expect to see Burrtec matching the amount Blue Barrel had bid for the commercial service. I’m just saying it...
— With two haulers, what does this mean in terms of waste diversion reporting? One of the reasons the local haulers (two WMI subsidiaries and a subsidiary of Republic Industries) have failed to meet state waste diversion requirements in Santa Clarita is confusion when it comes to reporting of waste totals. How will this be addressed in the new deal, especially if one hauler has residential and one has commercial?
— Where are they going to build the MRF? Whoever plans to build a MRF in Santa Clarita, you can bet your bottom dollar that they have SOME idea of where they want to put it. This should be discussed openly by the council and the haulers. I know they don’t want to engage in a land use debate at this juncture, but a MRF is like a short-term landfill — it’s a place where all the trash goes to get sorted. The potential locations should be publicly discussed.
— At the end of the day... To use the phrase that some of my business and government friends are so fond of saying, at the end of the day, what is more important: Getting what is simply the best deal or telling a hauler that has lied to your city to go pound sand?
I’ll be real honest: I hate some of the tactics that have been employed by WMI and its local subsidiary, Blue Barrel. This dates back several years, including notable acts like WMI’s local manager standing before our City Council and saying the $22.13 residential rate was the best they could do. I dare say that was a bald-faced lie. Take a look a the contract that comes out this week, and you’ll see a rate that’s much, much lower. WMI also said the local waste diversion goals were being met, when they weren’t. And, more recently, tried to use a discount for schools (untruthfully described as “free” service) in order to get local educators to strong-arm your city into giving WMI the contract.
Honestly, stuff like this just makes me want to say, “Throw the bastards out.”
But I’m going to try to endorse with my head and not my heart. I’m going to wait and seen what the new city staff recommendation says. A month ago, I urged the council to go with the staff recommendation at the time and give the whole contract to Burrtec, because Burrtec was offering what appeared to be the best deal at the time, and a lot of the enticing goodies in WMI’s deal were just talk, without a commitment on paper.
Now, it appears that may have changed. With the latest negotiations, it might just be that the best deal is one in which WMI gets the more lucrative contract — the residential — and Burrtec comes aboard to serve businesses. We can expect more of those details to emerge this week.
Plus, it became clear long ago that our City Council would never approve a deal that did not somehow involve Waste Management. To suggest otherwise in this town is akin to spitting into a hurricane. I guess those political loyalties run very, very deep.
Regardless, as much as I might, on an emotional level, want to see WMI told to shove off after its shenanigans in the past few years, I might just hold my nose and say, “It looks like the best deal. Take it.”
We shall see.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
