The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decided Tuesday that the city of Santa Clarita will be allowed to intervene in Cemex Inc.’s lawsuit against Los Angeles County.
The ruling overturns U.S. District Judge Dickran Tevrizian’s 2002 decision to deny the city a voice in court. Tevrizian determined that the city did not have enough of a legal interest in the 460-acre property where Cemex proposes to mine 78 million tons of sand and gravel to produce 56.1 million tons of concrete aggregate, used in home and road construction.
The three-judge appellate panel voted 2-1 in the city’s favor, deciding the city does have more than a passing interest in the case.
“The city has demonstrated that it has met the four-part test for intervention of right,” the panel stated in its decision.
The four-part test includes timeliness of the request to intervene; the demonstration of a “significantly protectable” interest in the property or the transaction in question; potential harm from an adverse ruling; and the uniqueness of its arguments.
An attorney for the city said the appellate panel’s decision was not influenced by the city’s recent $1 million purchase of 490 acres of land in Soledad Canyon, just outside city limits, where Cemex plans to mine.
“The court went back to our original situation, claiming to be a bordering city,” attorney Deborah Prosser said.
The appeals court also ruled the city’s strongest argument for a legally protectable interest was its right to be consulted under the California Environmental Quality Act, which “is directly related to Cemex’s action.”
Cemex received two 10-year mining permits in 1990 from the federal Bureau of Land Management, which controls the mineral rights.
Cemex argued that the federal government’s right to mine its minerals trumps any interest that might give the city reason to interfere.
However, the court ruled that the city “has a protectable interest in upholding the county’s application of CEQA against Cemex’s allegations of abuse of process and federal preemption.”
Cemex also argued that the city’s intervention would be superfluous since the county represents the same interest in protecting public health.
But the court ruled the “county has taken a more limited position,” and “the city has interests in the environmental review process independent of the county’s. Their interest may diverge.”
Prosser heralded the ruling as a major victory for the city of Santa Clarita.
The appellate decision came just moments after city officials expressed their “outrage” with a proposed settlement between Cemex and the county, filed with the court on Monday. The city called it “a total assault on environmental process.”
“We knew a settlement was coming and we’ve been preparing for it,” City Manager Ken Pulskamp said in a statement. “We have several strategies in place to continue our efforts to prevent the siting of this project as proposed. This is far from over.”
The city will request a continuance today of a hearing set for March 15, Prosser said. The opposition to the consent decree is due Monday, but Prosser said six days will not be enough time for city attorneys to analyze the voluminous documentation in the case.
“We’re asking for a continuance of at least 45 days,” she said. “Once we file the opposition, a hearing will be scheduled. The judge (Tevrizian) will make his decision whether or not to enter the consent decree as final judgment.”
Cemex spokesman Brian Mastin said all parties agreed to allow the city to participate in the hearings in an informal capacity as an amicus, or “friend of the court.”
“Now the city becomes another party in the case, which is what we all did not want,” Mastin said. “However, the court order does allow the district court to move forward with the consent decree. The city can intervene but they can’t go back into issues already presented in the case.”
Prosser said if the judge approves the settlement, the ruling by the appeals court becomes crucial.
“This was a very important win for us,” Prosser said. “If the consent decree becomes the final judgment, then we have the right to appeal that.”
