Santa Clarita Christian and Villanova Prep evenly weathered the aftermath of the earlier rains of this week for 63 minutes in their second round match in the CIF Division VI playoffs Tuesday.
But the Cardinals couldn’t weather the aftermath of a penalty in the 64th minute.
Slopping through the muddy Canyon High field, both teams were even at 2-2 in the 64th minute, when the referee’s whistle blew, 10 yards from the Cardinals’ goal.
As the Wildcats’ Chris Hur wrestled with two SCCS players for the ball, a penalty was called on the Cardinals for tripping, setting up a penalty kick.
Villanova’s Sean O’Malley booted the ball past SCCS goalkeeper Stephen Mercier, who could only freeze and watch it go past him.
The goal, O’Malley’s second in the game, would prove to be the game winner, 3-2.
“Unfortunately it was the difference in the game and as a referee that’s the last thing you want to be is the difference in the game, but you have to make the call,” SCCS coach Steve Cooper said. “It’s a courageous courage type of call when you know it’s going to be the difference in the game, so from that standpoint I don’t have a problem with the call.”
Neither did Cardinal players who said it was a borderline call.
“Both the defense and the other player tripped,” said Cardinal Orlandi Peña. “It was one of those calls that could have gone either way; it just happened to go for them and not us.”
Cooper and his team didn’t want to shift all the blame for the loss that ended the team’s season on the one call, though.
The Cardinals were up 2-0 in the first half, after all.
SCCS had the advantage in the first half with a pig sty of slop in front of Mercier, compared to a harder greener surface in front of Villanova goalie Ryan Whalen, allowing the Cardinals to maintain better footing.
That footing allowed the SCCS’ triple threat to attack 13 minutes into the game.
The Cardinals’ Kyle Doty tangoed around two Villanova defenders, then kicked the wet ball ahead to Peña who controlled it and directed it to James Richardson who delivered a weighted fastball past Whalen for a 1-0 lead.
Twenty minutes later, Doty booted a long liner in front of the net, Peña caught up after racing two defenders and chipped it in for a 2-0 lead.
In the first half’s final minute, O’Malley outraced Cardinal Nolan Patterson for the ball and Mercier stepped up out of the goalie box to challenge him. O’Malley grounded it past Mercier cutting the Cardinals’ lead to 2-1.
Switching sides for the second half, Mercier now had to deal with a more stable ground for Villanova’s offense.
And Villanova went right to work. A minute and 30 seconds in, the Wildcats’ June-Ho Shin picked up a loose ball on firmer ground, 10 yards from Mercier, then sent a hard shot to the back of the net tying the game.
“Us having that side of the field in the mud to begin with, that was advantageous to us and obviously in the second half it was advantageous to them,” Cooper said.
Up until the penalty kick, both teams played ball control, and SCCS struggled to get a shot off in the slop.
Case in point, the Cardinals had a last gasp with three minutes left. Peña sent a long pass to an open Doty near Villanova’s net, but the junior couldn’t get good footing to manage a shot.
“We had a perfect opportunity right in front of the goal. Had our player not slipped, the ball would have been in the back of the net,” Cooper said.
After the tough loss, the Cardinals (8-8-1) were already looking forward to next year, when Doty, Peña and Richardson will return for their senior years.
“This is our first year even winning a playoff game for our school,” Peña said. “It’s disappointing that one goal, one (penalty kick) puts us down, but we’re hoping for even better things next year.”
