This month marks the second anniversary of an incident that shook this community to the core. Outpourings of sympathy for the survivors quickly turned to rage as the facts became known — rage at the suspected perpetrator, and rage at the political system that offered him shelter.
On April 29, 2002, the Santa Clarita Valley lost one of its own.
It was Monday. The 33-year-old Saugus High School graduate awoke and readied himself for work, pulling on the uniform of a deputy sheriff for Los Angeles County.
It looked like it would be a perfect 72-degree Southern California day. The sun was just rising as he walked out the door of the Saugus home he shared with his wife and her young daughter.
Four and a half hours later he was cruising through Irwindale, when he signaled a driver to stop.
The driver pulled over and got out of the car. At first he seemed cooperative. He followed instructions to wait at the back of the vehicle.
There were questions about identification. At some point there was a call for backup.
As ordered, the driver turned around to assume a prone position. The rest is a blur. He fired once as he spun back around. The bullet missed the vest, ripping flesh and lodging in the chest.
The deputy fell to the ground.
The driver began to flee.
But had he killed him?
He might be identified if he left now. The deputy had seen him. He’d asked for identification. Was the deputy still alive?
He’d go back to jail, longer, surely, this time.
Odd. He’d been forced to return home so many times before, after doing less than he’d just done. Now the tables would be turned. Now the authorities in California would insist on having him back.
He wouldn’t take the chance. He stopped. Backup hadn’t arrived. No witnesses. He returned to the car. The deputy was still lying there.
He raised his gun. He fired once more. A direct, execution-style hit to the head.
By morning he was home in Mexico.
But the authorities had identified their suspect, and they did know exactly where he was.
They decided not to come after him.
Two years later, he is still a free man.
Who can blame the deputy’s widow for being frustrated? The time’s up, as far as she’s concerned. Two years of freedom is two years too long for the man who executed her husband.
But there’s a problem. Mexico won’t extradite killers to a country where they face the possibility of life in prison or the death penalty. In 2001 the Mexican supreme court ruled that a life sentence or death are cruel and unusual punishment.
That puts District Attorney Steve Cooley between a rock and a hard place.
Mexico used to cut deals in capital cases. It used to extradite with a promise of life in prison instead of death. Not anymore. Not since 2001.
Life in prison is no longer on the table.
So Cooley would have to agree to a term of something less than life. And California law doesn’t accommodate that for murder.
In California, first-degree murder and special-circumstance murder, like the murder of a police officer, carry a sentence of 25 years to life. Second-degree murder carries a sentence of 15 years to life.
The important words are “to life.” Minimum 15 or 25; after that, it’s up to some future parole board.
For Cooley to cut a deal Mexico would accept, he’d have to drop the charge to manslaughter, which carries a maximum sentence of 10 years.
That’s not acceptable to anyone, least of all Mr. Cooley.
Kill a cop, run to Mexico, you’ll get 10 years... It just doesn’t sound right.
There’s another option. If that was the “rock,” then the “hard place” is what would happen if Mexican authorities make the arrest and try the suspect in Mexico.
He won’t get life in prison, and there’s no guarantee he’ll get anything close.
So? Why not ask the Mexican government to arrest him any way? They might lock him up for some period of time, and if they acquit him, does it really matter? He’ll still be arrested if he sets foot in California, right?
Wrong.
Under California law, a suspect who has been acquitted or sentenced in another country for a crime committed here, can’t be retried for the same crime.
It doesn’t matter if the suspect is a murderer who kills a cop here, or a terrorist who blows up LAX. If he’s tried in another country for the crime and found either guilty or innocent, he can’t be retried here.
Steve Cooley has sponsored legislation in Sacramento to change that. Assembly Bill 1432, introduced last year by Marco A. Firebaugh, a South Gate Democrat who chairs the Latino Legislative Caucus, would overturn the portion of California’s double-jeopardy statute that applies in this case. The bill would allow California to retry someone who is tried first in another country for a crime committed here.
It’s a sensible bill and it’s hard to believe the law reads any other way today — although it has been that way since about 1873, when our state laws were first written.
Do a crime here, you should expect to face our criminal justice system.
The bill, subsequently co-authored by Assemblyman Keith Richman, passed the Assembly in January on a 72-2 vote. It moved to the state Senate, where it has been stuck since February, awaiting a hearing in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
The bill can’t be allowed to wallow, like it did last year when anti-death penalty activists in the Assembly bottled it up.
Call the Senate committee at (916) 322-1305 and rattle some cages in the offices of its members. They are Sens. John Burton, Bruce McPherson, John Vasconcellos, Bob Margett, Gloria Romero and Byron Sher. The bill needs to pass, and quickly.
Both Teri March and Steve Cooley are correct: It has been more than long enough. Armando Garcia needs to be behind bars, even if it’s in Mexico, and he needs to be returned to California to face trial here.
David March gave his life to protect us from killers. We owe him justice.
