There are lessons for both sides to learn in the City Council election held this past week.
First, the “environmentalist” side of the local political fence would be better served if it were well-organized and had a candidate who would energize anyone other than the Sierra Club. Henry Schultz came close — he nearly landed himself a four-year term on the City Council, despite running a fairly low-profile campaign and spending, relatively, very little money on it.
I like Henry well enough — I didn’t vote for him, but that wasn’t personal. As we wrote in The Signal’s endorsement editorial, it’s only natural for the local paper to endorse those candidates whose views are most consistent with the official editorial stance of the paper.
Same goes for my own vote — hence, my support of the incumbents, Bob Kellar and Cameron Smyth.
To be frank, I don’t think Henry exactly energized the anti-growth segment of the community; I’m happy with the result, but in watching this election unfold, it was a tale of a challenger who could have won — but didn’t muster the resources.
That, in a nutshell, is the lesson for both sides.
It’s certainly an alarm to sound for the pro-business Republican establishment in town. The final campaign spending reports are still a couple of months away, but the upshot will be that Schultz spent a tiny fraction of what Kellar spent, yet came within a little more than 700 votes of winning.
Suppose Schultz had it all together — a bit better fund-raising, a more engaging campaign, a bit more charisma... Bob Kellar, all of his expenditures aside, could easily be on the outside looking in.
What does that mean?
Well, contrary to what some of my political friends have been saying, this election does not, in any way, shape, or form, indicate the populace is “satisfied” with the incumbents.
When a relatively unknown challenger, with relatively poor “name ID” in town, can come within 800 votes of a big-spending incumbent while spending less than $10,000 — without the benefit of a political action committee bailing him out, like the one that bought Marsha McLean her council seat two years ago — well, it’s not exactly a “mandate.”
We had, as always, that segment of the population that passionately supports the “anti-growth” or “environmentalist” candidate. We also had that segment of the electorate that supports the hand-picked “pro-business” or “pro-development” (read: Newhall Land Republican) candidates, who, all political cynicism aside, happen to be those I support.
And, we had those citizens who don’t give a damn.
Whatever — among those who vote, Henry Schultz came within a whisper of unseating Bob Kellar, while spending a fraction of the money. Kellar won the seat, but this was a wake-up call: The anti-growth, pro-environment crowd shows up at the polls. They, coupled with those Republicans who vote selfishly — i.e., vote to stop growth despite the fact that to do so goes against their broader “free enterprise” principles — can determine the outcome.
It is a constituency that cannot be ignored.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.
