Let’s see if we’re understanding Judge Floyd Baxter correctly: A couple of news stories and one opinion column in the local newspaper are enough to “pollute” the Santa Clarita Valley jury pool sufficiently to not only warrant a change of venue for a criminal trial, but also to warrant a gag order on the defense attorney that forbids him from writing an unrelated opinion column in the newspaper.
Are we missing something here?
If the above is true — and we’ll confirm whether it is on Monday, when the transcript of Baxter’s Friday gag order ruling becomes available to The Signal — then it would be clear that the local judge has lost sight of a little thing called the First Amendment.
It’s understandable. You wear the robes long enough, people call you “your honor” long enough, they tiptoe in your presence long enough, and you can start to feel pretty all-powerful. That sort of thing can get to someone’s head.
In all fairness, there’s one ingredient in Baxter’s ruling that we cannot confirm until the transcript is released — the question of whether the judge has ordered a Signal columnist to stop writing.
That columnist is attorney Tony Zinnanti, an unpaid contributor who writes not only columns about legal issues, but also slice-of-life pieces. His topic this week: reflections on mortality during a hike through the Guatemalan jungle.
That’ll pollute the jury pool, won’t it?
As Zinnanti understood the ruling, the judge ordered him to refrain from talking to the media about the case of his client, Everett Scott, a probation officer accused of evading a police officer while trying to reach his wife at his Stevenson Ranch home during the Pico Canyon fire last fall. (We understand the very real need for police to control traffic so firefighters can do their jobs — and we advocate cooperation by the citizenry — but do you remember the days when trying to aid a damsel in distress made someone a hero? These days, they’ll prosecute you for it...)
In addition, Zinnanti said, the judge directed him to stop writing his column for The Signal — even though Zinnanti has not written about the Scott case. Again, we’ll confirm that aspect of Baxter’s ruling upon review of the transcript.
Either way, Baxter has clearly overstepped.
To say a couple of news stories and a separate column by Signal staff writer Diana Sevanian have “polluted” the jury pool in the Santa Clarita Valley is a stretch to say the least. We’re glad to accept the compliment — they don’t call this paper “The Mighty Signal” for nothing — but what has been written about the Scott case barely goes beyond routine coverage. If the Newhall court is going to send a case to San Fernando every time The Signal has a story or opinion column on it, they might as well shutter the local courthouse.
Further, Zinnanti has no more control over The Signal’s coverage than any other person who isn’t a member of our staff. He’s an unpaid contributor, with no editorial control whatsoever. Gagging him on this case is excessive, especially considering the fact that Baxter dished the case to San Fernando, and The Signal doesn’t circulate in the San Fernando Valley.
Occasionally a judge might issue a gag order to protect a defendant’s right to a fair trial. As much as we hate to see an infringement of anyone’s speech rights, that is sometimes understandable and necessary.
That, however, doesn’t appear to be what has happened here, and we can’t help wondering what Baxter’s real motivation was. We’d love to present his side of the story, but he has declined comment.
And just for the record: No, your honor, you cannot gag this newspaper.
That much, we know.
