Where do YOU draw the line?
The question couldn’t help coming up this week after an al-Qaida-affiliated Web site posted video of the beheading of American civilian Nicholas Berg in Iraq.
The terrorists, of course, posted video of the complete execution, preceded by the reading of an anti-American statement and punctuated by the sawing off of their captive’s head.
It’s not for the squeamish.
Or, so I’m told — I couldn’t even bring myself to view the video, much less publish it or broadcast it.
But in seeing and hearing the various ways in which the material was handled by media outlets, it reminded me once again that there is no uniform standard on what to publish or broadcast (nor can there be...). It’s subjective, and each situation presents its own unique set of circumstances.
This video is a particularly stark reminder. Suppose you are a newspaper editor: Which frame is the last frame that you’d be comfortable publishing as a still photo?
In our paper, the photo that appears here was the choice; it shows one of the terrorists pulling out the knife that would, a few moments later, be used to cut Berg’s head from his body.
Some media outlets didn’t go as far as that — while others went much further. One Los Angeles radio station repeated the audio from the slaughter several times. One television broadcast showed the video right up until the point at which the knife is pressed to Berg’s throat. Some newspapers chose shots similar to the one we chose. One Southland paper published a frame that showed Berg’s killer with the knife at the victim’s throat.
One Texas paper published a frame showing a terrorist holding up Berg’s severed head by the hair, and in the photo his facial features were digitally obscured.
Where’s the line? It depends. And it’s entirely subjective.
Images of news — and tragedy — are an important part of telling the story, in some cases more important than the words. That means sometimes we’ll decide to publish images that might make some readers uncomfortable.
As much as possible, it is our job to provide you an unblinking account of what’s happening here and in the world. Powerful stories call for powerful images — and it’s not our business to sanitize.
Yet, everyone has their limits.
My own personal limit is sometime between the pulling out of the knife and the placing of it against Berg’s throat. Anything beyond that crosses the line. For me, to show a graphic account of a beheading goes beyond the limits of acceptability, no matter the circumstances; it’s simply too graphic, too horrific.
I certainly can’t imagine publishing a picture of a severed head, even with digital tinkering.
This sort of debate is argued more easily when you’re talking about whether to publish a particular still image. It’s a thumbs-up or thumbs-down thing. But when you’re pulling images from a video, each frame is a decision to make.
Where would you draw the line?
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
