Just under two weeks ago, the Santa Clarita Valley lost two young men to yet another fatal auto wreck. The following is an excerpt of a letter to one of their friends in response to her note expressing concern about a crash photo published in The Signal.
Thanks for your letter. We of course will abide by your request that it not be published. And, please extend my sincere sympathies to everyone who was close to these young men. This was a tragic loss of two young, promising lives, and no one likes to see that happen.
I have a few thoughts I’d like to share, and I don’t expect you to agree. That is your prerogative, and I understand. I would, however, like to explain our thought processes under these circumstances. Perhaps it will help show we’re not just thoughtlessly or cruelly publishing such things without regard to their impacts. We wrestle with these issues every time they come up. Unfortunately, they come up all too often.
It is, first and foremost, our job to report and illustrate the news — good, bad or otherwise. That means we often show or tell our readers things they may rather not see. This doesn’t mean we have no boundaries. We won’t publish photos that could be classified as “gory.” Typically we won’t publish photos showing the body of a dead person. But it is not uncommon for us, or other media outlets, to publish photos that show a covered body, as was the case with this incident.
This isn’t done recklessly. It’s done to bring home the powerful nature of what happened, and, hopefully, to remind everyone this crash was not just a wrecked car. We’re not always right. It is a subjective part of our job, and the decisions are often difficult.
Several years ago, there was a horrible crash in which six young people were killed. They had not been wearing seat belts and were ejected from the car. We were having an intense debate over whether to publish the most powerful photo: It showed a CHP officer draping a sheet over one of the bodies, and the overturned car was behind him. Because the photo was taken from a long distance, the body was not recognizable.
I polled the top editors in the newsroom. Half said to run it and half said not to. At that point, one of our writers — a mother of three — walked past the computer where we were analyzing the photo and said, “If it makes one kid buckle up, I’d run it.”
I’m a parent. I decided to run the photo. I took a fair amount of heat for it, but I believed it was the right thing to do. It wasn’t done with malice toward the victims or their families, but out of hope that, by bringing home just how tragic the crash was, we might prevent someone else from meeting the same fate.
I know none of this will make you feel any better. That’s understandable. You’ve lost two close friends, and I am truly sorry for that. I just hope you can understand — we don’t take these decisions lightly.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager.
