ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Los Angeles: A History of Dumping on the SCV

Ladies and gentlemen, may I introduce the pot and the kettle...

The city of Los Angeles has a long and storied history of “outsourcing” problems to the Santa Clarita Valley, dating back nearly a century. Yet, when the city of Santa Clarita reached a $36,000 agreement with Lutheran Social Services to help the local homeless, a passel of politicians and a newspaper columnist from L.A. cried foul because the plan included provisions for SOME of the local homeless to be taken to regional shelters like the one in Sylmar.

To hear them tell it, Santa Clarita was exporting undesirables to Los Angeles, sweeping them under the rug while we all slurp caviar and sip champagne.

Santa Clarita may make an easy target, but that’s simply not a fair or accurate portrayal.

We’ve editorialized accordingly — and pointed out that social services like sheltering the homeless are more the county’s role than the city’s. Thankfully, county Supervisor Mike Antonovich has stepped in with a plan for at least a short-term local shelter option.

But Santa Clarita has been wrestling with this for years, and this year, the city’s plan involved a locally led effort to provide homeless services — things like counseling, job assistance, vouchers for shelter in local motels and, yes, in some cases, transportation to a regional shelter.

That shelter, by the way, happens to be closer to Valencia than it is to downtown L.A.

What really struck me about the reaction from the L.A. folks — particularly skid row Councilwoman Jan Perry — was the hypocrisy of it.

Who are they to gripe about Santa Clarita exporting problems to L.A.?

Beyond the fact that it’s preposterous to think our estimated 96 homeless (out of 80,000 countywide) will become a burden to LOS ANGELES, of all places, there is the history of the relationship between L.A. and the SCV.

The city of L.A. has never been shy about sending its problems way out here to the sticks.

OK, this first one may be a stretch — but you could say it all started with the St. Francis Dam. William Mulholland’s dam of death was built to help Los Angeles win the water wars of the early 20th century. Design and judgment errors led to the St. Francis Dam disaster March 12, 1928. Some 450 people were killed when the dam burst, sending a churning wall of water from San Francisquito Canyon to the ocean.

And, as you might have guessed, SCV residents didn’t get a drop of that water until they drowned in it.

Fortunately, after that, Los Angeles stopped actually killing Santa Clarita Valley residents, so the death toll in this relationship hovers at around 450. But L.A.’s efforts to rain destruction upon the SCV were far from over.

Los Angeles started exporting its garbage — literally — to the SCV in the 1940s, when the city of L.A. created new zoning restrictions to outlaw garbage-eating pig farms. Where did they want to send L.A.’s garbage?

To new hog farms in the Santa Clarita Valley, of course.

SCV residents rose up and objected, signing petitions, holding town meetings and generally fighting the good fight.

It appeared in 1951 the long-running battle to outlaw hog farms here was lost, when Los Angeles struck a new contract to send its trash to hog farms in the SCV.

Then-Signal publisher Fred Trueblood editorialized: “The great hog war is over. The hogs have won.”

The hog permit would later be canceled, and trash-eating hog farms would become a thing of the past.

But the SCV’s battles with the city of Los Angeles would continue.

Apparently not satisfied with exporting its garbage, L.A. decided to send us its drunks, too. On the hill above the present-day Central Park, where the Castaic Lake Water Agency offices now sit, is the site of the former Saugus Rehabilitation Center, where alcoholics from, you guessed it, Los Angeles, were sent to dry out, up here in the boonies where they wouldn’t offend the dainty sensibilities of Angelenos.

And finally, there’s my favorite, the proposed Elsmere Canyon landfill.

The details of these sorts of things tend to get glossed over when we write about them in a historical context, but one of the first big ongoing stories I covered as a reporter about 15 years ago was the joint agreement between the county and city of Los Angeles to pursue the development of the world’s largest landfill in Elsmere Canyon.

You see, the city of Los Angeles wanted to solve its trash crisis — this time, not with hogs, but still by sending its trash out here, to your back yard.

The proposal called for 190 million tons of trash — most of it from, where else, Los Angeles — to be dumped in a pristine canyon that was perched upslope from our underground water supply. But Los Angeles didn’t give a rat’s tucchus about your drinking water.

Fortunately, the proposed dump site was in the Angeles National Forest and our congressman, local activists and the city of Santa Clarita came to the rescue.

It was just the latest in a decades-long line of battles we had to wage to protect ourselves from the garbage-spewing scourge on the other side of the hill.

But heaven forbid a few of our homeless should take temporary shelter in Sylmar, where on any given night Los Angeles’ own homeless would be getting a hot and a cot anyway. Plus, the LSS and Santa Clarita would PAY for it.

The politics of it heated up quickly — thanks in part to well-placed stoking from a big-city newspaper columnist who visited the SCV for a few hours and decided he therefore knew enough to draw broad conclusions about Santa Clarita and its leaders. Now, the L.A. City Council has adopted a resolution saying the homeless from other cities (especially Santa Clarita, I guess) will not be accepted in L.A. shelters.

That’s the benevolent spirit. Merry Christmas to you, too. Good thing the Statue of Liberty isn’t greeting ships at the Port of Los Angeles.

Over the past seven years, when a winter shelter has operated on Santa Clarita property, they never rejected a homeless person because he was “from” L.A. The only requirement was that one follow the shelter’s rules of conduct and, of course, actually be homeless.

Other than raising the question, “If you’re homeless, where are you from, really?” the tiff between Santa Clarita and Los Angeles only serves to remind us that this has pretty much always been a one-sided relationship.

Over the years, the SCV has nearly always gotten the short end of the stick in its dealings with the city of Los Angeles. The metropolis to the south is only too happy to play the role of Big Dog, and treat the SCV as its own personal fire hydrant.

On second thought, this really isn’t a case of the pot and the kettle. Our city has done nothing wrong here — and Los Angeles has no business calling Santa Clarita black.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column appears Sundays.

← Back to 2004

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:5924.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,184 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [General Manager]
  • text:valley_names [9 distinct/34 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Saugus, City Council, Castaic Lake Water, Elsmere]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Antonovich”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0